downloadTheology & History
Alternative Worship In The Pentecostal-Charismatic Tradition
The charismatic movement brought classical Pentecostalism into contact with other major traditions from which it had been estranged. Many younger Pentecostals are experiencing renewal in worship through this encounter, combining their Pentecostal heritage with evangelical and liturgical influences.
Classical Pentecostalism differs from the charismatic movement in many respects. A generation ago members of historic denominations that had experienced phenomena usually connected with Pentecostals, such as tongue-speaking, prophetic speech, and exorcism, were given the name "charismatic." The charismatics borrowed much from their Pentecostal friends, of course, but rejected much of their cultural mores. The Pentecostal-Charismatic Encounter The charismatic movement presented the classical Pentecostals with a real dilemma. They wanted to identify with the charismatics, but the conservative elements in Pentecostalism rejected the context in which the charismatics' experiences were happening. Early in its history Pentecostalism had divorced itself, and been divorced from, the rest of Christendom. As in most divorces, this one brought its share of hurt and bitterness. Pentecostals had learned to deal with the alienation by claiming to occupy at least a place of prominence in the Christian church, and sometimes even to have replaced "backslidden" Christendom. Now, after all these years, Pentecostals had to deal with the new tongues speakers. At first they put pressure on the charismatics to leave the historic denominations. The charismatics resisted this pressure for the most part, and in the cases where they did leave, they tended to form their own independent churches. Many of these new congregations became thriving megachurches, some of which began to exercise enormous influence on younger generations of Pentecostals. The younger people began to prefer the praise music and dance of the newer charismatics to the older traditions of spontaneous spiritual dance and frontier revivalistic hymns. All of this became the subject of many a conference and camp meeting. The internal debates within classical Pentecostalism continue, but it is especially pronounced in the more isolated branches of the movement, such as the Church of God of Prophecy and the United Pentecostal Church. Larger bodies such as the Assemblies of God are not unaffected either, however. The struggle is nowhere more obvious than in style of worship. The classical Pentecostals borrowed their worship from two main sources: the holiness Methodism of the frontier and the black churches. This background accounts for the mixture of high emotion together with what had been features of the more liturgical churches, such as anointing with oil and the laying on of hands. The Pentecostals retained the features of their own frontier background and rarely questioned whether the Pentecostal experience could ever emerge in any other cultural context. Most of the independent charismatic megachurches tended to be Baptist in doctrine, church government, and preaching style. So as Pentecostals began to meet their charismatic counterparts, they first found themselves stretching to accommodate Baptist streams of thought. They had hardly caught their breath when they had to face as well the liturgical charismatics from Lutheran, Episcopalian, Roman Catholic, and Orthodox backgrounds. Their fathers had barely studied these people in Bible schools; this generation was meeting them face to face! The Pentecostals were like the Jewish friends of St. Peter at the house of Cornelius who came back to Jerusalem with the report, "we heard them speak with tongues as we did in the beginning." The younger Pentecostals began to experience an identity crisis. Who were they, and where were they going? Pentecostal Diaspora An understanding grew among them that the church of Jesus Christ, like her God, has a triune nature: sacramental, evangelical, and Pentecostal. Christians should reverence the majesty of God, proclaim the redemptive work of God, and announce the powerful kingdom of God. The church needs priestly pastors, rabbinical and scholarly teachers, and fiery prophets. The younger Pentecostals began to feel that it would take the whole church to reach the whole world. So while Pentecostalism was influencing the whole church, and the new generation of Pentecostals wanted to remain a part of that influence, they also believed it was time for the whole church to influence Pentecostalism. In other words, the younger Pentecostals no longer see renewal as something flowing in only one direction. Some of the Pentecostal denominations are coping with this development better than others. In some groups the younger ministers have been routinely ostracized from the movement. Some of them, sadly, have been alienated even from their families. In response to this, several groups have sprung up that allow friends and colleagues to make their spiritual journey together. One of them, Global Christian Ministries, came into being in the early 1980s. By 1986 this group had developed a Confession of Faith based on the Apostles' Creed, and quickly become a network that brings together people from evangelical, Pentecostal, and liturgical backgrounds. The churches and ministers involved in this Pentecostal diaspora are studying the church fathers, liturgies of churches Eastern and Western, and in general becoming connected with their Christian heritage, without, however, rejecting their own Pentecostal experience. As might be expected, this endeavor has had a great impact on the way they worship. Contemporary music, black gospel, charismatic praise choruses, and historic hymns blend in a strange but fulfilling collage of musical ecumenism. Written prayers mingle with highly charged extemporaneous intercession. Banners are carried in processionals into the sanctuary, accompanied by shouts of joy. The influence of the church year is growing, adding a new rhythm to the churches. Everywhere one sees copies of The Book of Common Prayer. Some churches, such as the Church of the King in Valdosta, Georgia, have moved their affiliation from a Pentecostal denomination to that of a historical denomination (in their case, from the Assemblies of God to the Episcopal church). Most however, continue to move together in a loose network, studying, experimenting, interacting, and worshiping. No one knows exactly what direction this movement will take, but it has already resulted in a deeper understanding of the sacraments, a pattern of worship closer to that of antiquity, and an experience of worship that combines celebration with adoration and solemnity.