Back to Media & Articles Library
downloadTheology & HistoryWorship Leading

Corruption Of Worship By Manipulation And Utilitarianism

ByWorshipedia

Worship is sometimes used as a tool for the manipulation of human experience. The true function of worship is not to lead people through a sequence of emotional states, to effect their behavioral change, or to promote programs or special emphases of the church or denomination. Rather, the purpose of worship is to glorify God in the world.

A common corruption of worship is one we may call a corruption of function: the authoritarian structuring of worship to fit preconceived ideas without primary fidelity to the nature of the God revealed in the gospel. Many pastors, for example, feel led to provide guidelines for the congregation by introducing categories into the printed order (e.g., "Hymn of Consecration"). Such structuring may not be out of place when conceived with theological integrity and a certain pastoral diffidence; but it easily becomes a mechanizing of worship in order to compel the worshipers' devotion to conform to the leader's plans. Indeed, the presumptuousness of theologians in laying down liturgical structures with heavy-handed authority can easily become an idolatrous imposing of man-made structures upon the sovereign nature of the Word and a violation of the integrity of the human soul to respond to the Word in a Spirit-directed way. The psychological rigging of worship classically illustrates this type of corruption, in which attention to people and the dynamics of personal experience is made sovereign rather than the nature and action of the Word. Commonly this corruption is a compound of more or less religious humanism and shreds of theology embodied in such frank declarations that the primary purpose of worship is "to foster the religious experience"—that worship is "to break down inhibitions" and "expand perceptions." The worshiper's feelings in particular are played upon (as well as his tactile senses in certain experimental liturgies), and the experience thus aroused, together with discussion about it, are made the content of liturgy. Such devices as "cycles" or "sequences" are employed to execute this purpose. We find "theme worship" with all parts of the service chosen to reinforce "the motif of the morning." But clearly, to conceive worship primarily within the category of the psychology of human experience is not only to subvert its purpose as the worship of God. It is also to risk committing liturgical suicide in that an endless train of corruptions follow from this basic corruption; for worship as the contrived fostering of experience for the sake of experience opens the door to all kinds of manipulative devices, with only the leader of worship answerable for their legitimacy. To a degree we have anticipated the next corruption to be identified—the using of worship primarily to achieve humanly chosen ends; we may call it the corruption of "utilitarianism." Forms of this corruption are legion. On a crude level they include blasphemous invitations to worship which appeal to nothing more than self-interest and practices of worship which would be amusing were they not so pernicious. Worship as a means of "character building" and of producing "socially motivated personality," worship as a means to "self-fulfillment" and "success," invitations to worship in the vein of "come to church this week, you'll feel better, do better, live better, it's the American way"—such are the more noxious expressions. The alliance of worship with political nationalism and its degeneration into modern tribalism must also be noted. Occasionally this perversion is clear-cut and thoroughgoing, at other times subtle or naive, though no less demonic. Utilitarianism is also evident in the propagandizing with which denominational bureaucracies utilize worship for "promotion" and "cultivation." "Board of Pensions Sunday" is substituted for the First Sunday in Advent, or "Rural Church Sunday" for the feast of Pentecost; or the meaning of Worldwide Communion is measured by whether or not the amount of money collected surpasses last year's record. Perhaps the humorless hand of bureaucracy was evident at its worst in a "Crusade for Morality" launched by one denomination, in which the Sundays of the year were divided into five "emphases" with "worship and sermon" tailored to fit. Sundays in the fall were preempted for "abstinence from beverage alcohol, and personal moral regeneration," and "clean sex behavior" was laid down as the theme for Sundays in the spring! Nevertheless, the center of gravity for liturgical reflection and decision must always remain God, the End beyond all other ends even as he is implicit in all other ends. To affirm this truth, to be sure, is not to subscribe to the theological cliché one often hears: that worship always and everywhere should be conducted soli Deo Gloria, to the glory of God alone. For the God encountered in worship is never alone, and his glory always has to do with man and his life. The God of Christian devotion is always a God in relation to man and man's world, and his glory inheres in that grace which by definition has man and his moral life as its object. Indeed, in a sense God is glorified to the extent that man is ethicized. Nevertheless, worship is first to be conceived as encounter with God; its reference is secondarily to man.
Discuss This Topic with AI Worship CoachBrowse Structured Courses