downloadTheology & History
Experiencing The Faith-Story In Worship
The worship environment is uniquely equipped to transmit the historical perspective that is foundational to biblical faith. Through the drama of rite and ritual, worshipers learn to experience and retell the faith-story, which embodies the Christian community's sense of identity.
Sustained observation of the work of people engaged in religious education reveals a primary concern with cognitive, rather than creative, learning tasks. The majority of teachers are faithful, caring, committed persons; some are exceptional teachers; a few are engaged in truly creative learning experiences with children. In most cases, however, learning tasks have been controlled by teachers, who are primarily concerned with the mastery of cognitive skills and the direct transmission of information, facts, or concepts. Creative activities, if used at all, have been supplementary. It is true that a good deal of significant change has taken place in religious education in recent years. Nevertheless, while many creative teaching methods are being employed, religious education is primarily focused on the discovery of the general, the universal, and the abstract, rather than on the idiosyncratic, the concrete, and the experiential. Learning in religious education, in spite of many exciting innovations, is still dominantly verbal, conceptual, and analytic. The development of the intellect is primary. Little attention is given to intuition and the affections. The price to be paid for this educational imbalance is great: it may be making learning to pray difficult. Participation in the arts as well as more structured opportunities for effective learning will be necessary. No longer can we, Christians, permit people to neglect the touch, smell, or taste of life; to escape the expressing of feelings; or to avoid creative expression through the use of the arts. However, a rebirth of concern for the affections and the nurture of the intuitive mode of consciousness is not enough. As long as we continue our present educational practices, which neglect the development of a historicist perspective, true Christian prayer will avoid us. Therefore, we need to focus on the development of historical awareness. The Judeo-Christian faith is founded upon a historicist perspective. Within the cumulative tradition of the faith, God is understood as one who acts—to create the world and all creatures, to sustain the world through interaction with those creatures according to the purposes of God, and to bring the world and all God has made to the ends for which God created them. God is an incarnate agent, who acts on and in the world. History is, therefore, intentional and directional. Through God's revelatory historical actions, we understand the past, gain hope for the present, and receive a vision of the future. Our lives, and indeed life itself, takes on meaning and purpose in the light of that story. The significance of the biblical understanding of God as the one who acts is founded upon an understanding of the whole course of history; that is, history which is ordered toward God's ultimate goal—the kingdom of God. With the ultimate goal of history as our vision, we can understand the present and interpret the past. Religious education, therefore, ought to focus on helping people to live in and for God's kingdom, to live in the light of a hoped-for future, and to understand their place in life as essentially historical agents committed to fulfilling themselves through the exercise of their wills in reflective action. To accomplish these goals, we will need to consider how people acquire their perspective or view of the world. Gordon Kaufman suggests that we as humans relate to the world in one or more ways: through thinking, feeling, and acting. Each approach to experience results in a particular way of viewing the world. A dominance of thinking tends to issue forth in a secular worldview, a view which ignores the depth of reality and our desire for insight about the future. Kaufman also suggests that when feeling is given a dominant place in shaping our understanding of life, a religious worldview results. Such a view of the world, while affirming the importance of the affections, neglects the moral dimensions of our volitional life. Only when we make action the dominant mode of our world viewing do we establish what Kaufman describes as a theistic worldview, a perspective that speaks of a reality other than humanity and the world. "?Theism takes the world to be ordered from beyond itself by intentional and purposeful activity rooted in the will of God?" (Gordon Kaufman, God the Problem [Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1972], 219). Life according to this latter worldview is understood as derivative from God and God's purposes as revealed in God's historical action. Each of us is a thinking, feeling, willing self. For too long, we have emphasized either our thinking or feeling natures in religious education. We need to reemphasize our lives as praxis—willing, passionate, reflective action. In the English language, faith is a noun, a word that refers or points to something else—a person, place, or thing. If we think of faith as a thing, we can easily say that we have "?found it?" or "?lost it.?" From this point of view, faith is a possession understood as personal salvation, spirit (joy in the Lord), a resource for personal living, or knowledge. But it is more hopeful to think of faith as a centered integrated action, as a verb. We should speak of "?being faithful?" rather than of "?having faith.?" Speaking of being faithful rightly emphasizes the integration of thinking, feeling, and willing. Faith is a matter of who we are, of how we think, and of what we do in response to what God does for us and how God acts in history. For this understanding of faith to take shape in our lives, we need also to develop a historical consciousness. Such a historicist perspective is encouraged by participation in the life of a history-bearing community of faith, whose past is made present and personal. Too often, if we have told our story at all, we have told it as if it were a series of separate past events with a minimum of personal significance. For example, we recall how God once upon a time freed some Israelites from bondage in Egypt. How much more significant to relate this to God's action in our own lives, in which God freed us in our bondage once, continues to free us, and will free us ultimately. If we continue to place our emphasis in religious education on doctrine (what persons ought to believe) or on the Bible (sacred literature to be learned), we will continue to make that historicist perspective, which is necessary for prayer, difficult to acquire. Instead, we need to consider directing our educational efforts toward storytelling. We need to transmit in meaningful ways the story of our faith, the story of God's historical acts in the lives of the people of God. From the earliest years, in the context of a celebrating faith community, children, youth, and adults need to experience the faith-story through song, dance, drama, and the visual arts. It will be necessary for us to learn "?our story?" in ways that make the past part of the present and future. We need to seek ways to communicate the story as our story. When we have become involved in that sort of religious education, we will have begun to lay the foundations for the Christian life of prayer. Only when daily prayer (our conscious awareness of God's presence in our personal and social history) is a natural part of our lives will ritual prayer be purposeful. We do not proceed from ritual prayer to prayer; it is the other way around. Good rituals express and telescope our experience. Without experience, rituals remain dead forms. Revelation and Response Faith is a response to revelation. Revelation and faith belong together, just as theology and religion do. To speak of religion is to speak of institutions, documents, artifacts, customs, ceremonies, credal statements, and codes of conduct. Faith, on the other hand, is deeply personal and dynamic. Faith is not a result of a purely rational process. It is affectional, a relationship with God, which embraces the whole person and about which it is difficult to be objective. To be sure, faith always expresses itself in religion; and, as such, religion provides us with the means by which we grow in faith. There is a difference between learning about the doctrine of salvation and being saved. There is a difference between understanding justification by faith and being justified by it. There is a difference between understanding religion and religious experience and having an experience of God's presence. Faith is not knowledge about, or even intellectual assent to, truth or ideas. It is a response to a person. Our ideas about God are important. Indeed, they can influence the sort of experiences of God we have and do not have. In one sense then, our revelation of God is made possible through the ideas of God, which are passed on through the tradition. But that is only a partial truth. Our experiences frame and form our ideas. People in the first century experienced the resurrected Christ and his presence at the breaking of the bread. Their ideas about God and God's new community were framed by that relational experience, which, metaphorically, we communicate each time we celebrate the Lord's Supper. To become aware of God's continuing revelation is to nurture the intuitional mode of consciousness. Our faith experiences are always translated (and need to be) into religious beliefs. This process of institutionalization involves the symbolic transformation of the experience of God into less than ultimate forms. While this bringing of the sacred into profane structures is necessary, it provides a dilemma for the church. Since the faith experience of revelation is spontaneous and creative, the necessary institutionalization of revelation reduces such experience. Ritual and Re-presentation Ritual is a social drama, which embodies the memories and visions of a community. It is through the repetition of these symbolic actions that we evoke the feeling of the primordial event, which initially called the community into being with such power that it affects a present presence at that event. In other words, through the intuitional mode of consciousness, ritual re-presents revelation. An example would be the Christian rituals of baptism or the Lord's Supper, both of which re-present the event of Jesus' death and resurrection. Through the power of symbolic actions, we order our experience; through the use of symbolic narrative, we explain our lives. Ritual operates on those levels of existential reality that undergird the conceptual. More importantly, ritual points to and participates in that primordial truth, which is located at the expanding edge of our horizon of knowing, in feeling and intuition, not in common sense or thinking. Without ritual, life becomes mundane and profane. For it is through ritual expression of the symbolic and through the foundational intuitive mode of consciousness that the sacramental and the sacred are best known and expressed. When we participate in a ritual, we experience community. We reconcile and identify ourselves with our foreparents from whom the ritual has descended. And we reestablish continuity with the past and a vision for the future. Ritual is drama; it is life in the world of the receptive mode of consciousness. When our intuition atrophies, our rituals lose their power. Correspondingly, meaningful ritual can enhance and enliven our intuitional mode of consciousness. Therefore unless ritual is raised to its proper significance, our spiritual lives will remain impotent.