Back to Media & Articles Library
downloadTheology & HistoryWorship Leading

McEucharist: The Allure Of "Fast-Food" Worship

ByWorshipedia

In their concern to reach as many people as possible with the gospel of Christ, church leaders often try to make the worship service as attractive as possible for the unchurched. When worship planning is "consumer-driven," however, serious abuses of true worship may result. The author of this entry raises some thoughtful questions about the "fast-food" approach to worship.

This is a day in which church leaders are frequently admonished to be culturally sensitive to visitors and the unchurched in their preparation and execution of worship. In a sense this appears to be wise counsel. However, an inherent danger in striving to be culturally relevant is that the church will instead become culturally driven. Indeed, in observing the push toward becoming all things to all men one might wonder whether some promoters of cultural sensitivity have not become imprisoned by the need to reach their market, regardless of how much their efforts might compromise the message of Jesus Christ. The popular view among those who see the church as a product to be marketed is that worship is a consumer-driven service. That is to say, those areas of worship which might not appeal to visitors or non-Christians should be minimized or even eliminated in order to allow time for maximizing more appealing portions of the service. One of these persons boasted to a seminar group that his church of 2200 has become so efficient that it can take the collection in 90 seconds. As if that were not impressive enough, he went on to affirm that it can serve communion to the same number of people in just two minutes. The secret is that the plates holding bread and juice are placed under every fourth pew. At the appropriate time a designated person at the end of each pew simply reaches down to retrieve the plates and send them speeding down each row. In exactly two minutes the entire church can be served. This is a somewhat shocking example of what we might call "fast-food worship." It must be wondered to what extent this particular church might go to satisfy its customers. On the subject of McEucharist, therefore, some questions need to be asked. Does God Like to Be Rushed? First of all we might ask if God enjoys being rushed or manipulated. While not every person enters a church service with pure motives, from a biblical perspective the purpose of this gathering is to recognize God and respond to him with appropriate joy and gratitude. This implies that the God who is greater than the humans who meet together in his name is the one who sets the agenda for worship, and not the reverse. Certainly God wants outsiders to be invited and made comfortable in order that they might also discover, experience, and embrace the gospel of Jesus Christ. The question is, how much is the church willing to sacrifice and compromise for the purpose of making worship exciting and inviting? Are there limits in the areas of theology and taste which must not be violated? Or do we feel we have the right and responsibility to alter the practice of worship to such an extent that we actually mar the reflection of the nature of God in the process? The Scriptures remind us to slow down (Ps. 46:10) and to linger in and enjoy the presence of Jesus Christ (Luke 10:38–42). They call us to wait on the Lord, not to hurry the Almighty so that his appearance can fit into our overpacked schedules (cf. Ps. 27:14; Prov. 20:22; Isa. 8:17; Hos. 12:6; etc.). It is difficult to believe that rushing at breakneck speed through certain parts of the liturgy in order to arrive at others we might deem more "appealing" is a healthy or balanced way of viewing either worship or God himself. Is Worship Entertainment? Second, we should ask whether we have changed worship from that which we offer and give to God into something we receive and get for ourselves. Liturgy is supposed to be the work of the people, but it is in danger of becoming the entertainment of the people instead. In some churches it becomes a reflection of our passive society in which we are only spectators, rather than an activity into which we enter and in which we participate with God and our fellow worshipers. Some worship professionals have advanced the idea that the primary role of the pastor is to lead the congregation and not, himself, to worship. Another maxim of the culturally sensitive philosophy is that a congregation would rather listen to music sung to them than to actually sing music themselves. Inherent in these statements seems to be a conviction that the probability of God's presence and blessing in the service increases exponentially with the professional quality of the entertainment. Is "Canned" Music an Act of Worship? A third consideration, and one related to the idea of worship as entertainment, is the change that has been taking place in church music. In recent years the advancements of technology have interacted with the taste of consumers to produce a new style of electronic music. In the church this change has manifested itself in the proliferation of accompaniment tapes and music "tracks." Initially these were used only for the purpose of guiding choirs or soloists. However, their use in providing dubbed-in voices to augment the background is becoming increasingly common. One can only wonder who is accompanying whom. While these technological advances may offer the small church a ready means of providing quality music, it can also have the result of marginalizing music. The message conveyed is that there is no need for members of a congregation to learn to play the piano, organ, or guitar. Indeed, even where there are those capable of providing live accompaniment, the difference in skill level between them and the professionals on the tape may lead the church to opt for electronic music. This minimizes participation in worship by those in the church who are gifted for this very purpose. In addition, the use of canned music has fostered a dangerous and unhealthy concept known as "special music." This usually translates into a soloist or small ensemble who travel from church to church to minister. Since very little, in any, relationship may exist between the "special music" and the specific congregation, the selection of songs will probably neither blend with nor enhance the worship style of that church. The result is a "time out" for entertainment instead of participation in worship. The use of outside groups to lure non-members into the church sometimes fosters competition among churches, with each one feeling pressure to keep up with others in its area and bring in a better or more widely-known traveling group to satisfy its own members and attract potential new ones. This emphasis further discourages the members of a local church in developing and offering their own gifts and musical abilities. Yet a foundational biblical principle of worship is that it is participatory. Is Worship a Means to Accomplishing Something Else? In the fourth place, the consumer philosophy suggests a dangerous inversion of means and ends. According to the Bible, God's people engage in worship because it is what he enjoys. Worship is the way in which we honor and adore our covenant Lord. This implies that worship is of value in and of itself. In other words, worship is an end. It is not primarily a tool for evangelizing or attracting visitors or for recruiting teachers for Sunday school or advisors for the youth group. Neither is it intended to motivate or manipulate people into increasing contributions to the church. Nor is it a means to challenge people to become more involved in social justice or any other legitimate dimension of the church. These approaches all view worship as a means to accomplishing something else. The problem with this distorted approach is that if worship is essentially designed to recruit, evangelize, inspire stewardship, or for any other purpose, it will rarely reach the ultimate goal of focusing on God. On the other hand, worship which begins with the assumption that God is the first priority, and which is developed in a biblical and balanced manner, will not only glorify and lead people into God's presence, but will also fulfill the secondary purposes of inspiring them to acts of devotion and service. Writing in the early part of this century, Willard Sperry observed: "Things which are ends in themselves move us far more profoundly than things which are simply means to other ends" (Reality in Worship [New York: MacMillan, 1925], 249). Worship structured around gimmicks and glitter will neither glorify God nor provide people with anything of integrity. When this approach is used, it results in a desire for the gifts and blessings of God rather than a seeking after God himself. In other words, it creates another example of consumerism in which persons attending church assume that they are in charge and can "have it their way." This is not to say that the market-driven approach to worship might not please a church initially. The pastor and other church leaders might be happy because the revamped worship style is attracting large numbers of visitors. The visitors and congregation might also be relieved that this method of worship requires less involvement and participation from them and is entertaining and therefore enjoyable. However, on a deeper level we must ask how this philosophy of worship will shape the worshipers' image of God and their response to the needs of our broken world. Another consideration is the effect it will have on the foundation and depth of the individual's faith. Eugene Peterson examines the problem with characteristic wisdom when he writes: "The initial consequence is that leaders substitute image for substance, satisfying the customer temporarily, but only temporarily" (Under the Unpredictable Plant: An Exploration in Vocational Holiness [Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1992], 3). Worship which is not solidly grounded in substance often leaves people with a spiritual void that they attempt to fill by seeking more exciting worship experiences, often without success. This dissatisfaction might be avoided if Christians learned from worship that God is the Creator and we are his creatures, and not the reverse. Are Some Parts of Worship Less Appealing Than Others? In the fifth place, the church should examine the idea inherent in consumer-driven worship philosophy that certain parts of the liturgy are more or less appealing than others. It is common to hear the unchurched criticize the church for collecting funds, because this practice threatens or irritates them. Certainly, the solicitation of money has sometimes been abused by various religious groups. Some churches may place an excessive emphasis on money or be guilty of poor stewardship of those resources entrusted to them. However, it might also be observed that other churches might overemphasize music or preaching or some other aspect of worship. It is well known that any portion of a worship service can be used to draw a person into the presence of God and thus transform him or her. It is not uncommon for parishioners to comment that the prayer of confession, offering, benediction, moments of silence, or the use of a banner or other symbol brought to them a fresh and enhanced experience of God's presence. Each worshiper is touched by a different aspect of the service which becomes for him or her the most significant one on that particular day. An individual's personality and background play a role in differential response to different parts of the church service. Indeed, many debates that ignite fireworks and divide congregations originate in issues of personality preferences rather than in theology. The Spiritual Cost of McEucharist. An American desire for efficiency is deeply embedded in the church-marketing ideology. A church which can produce a better, more exciting, and more entertaining worship service will draw more people and thereby become a success. But the Christian community must determine the eventual cost of streamlining worship in an attempt to make it more attractive. Gerald May comments on this issue when he writes: "By worshiping efficiency, the human race has achieved the highest level of efficiency in history, but how much have we grown in love?" (The Awakened Heart: Living Beyond Addiction [San Francisco: Harper Collins, 1991], 10). Worship is ultimately a relationship of love in which we focus on and respond to God. Unfortunately, the strongly pragmatic emphasis of the proponents of consumer-driven churches often obscures this relational component to worship. In fact, the persistent influence of pragmatism narrows the focus to simply what works. This so-called cost-efficient means of conducting worship tends in time to erode any sense of mystery and wonder in the presence of God. It creates instead a simplistic perception of God that categorizes life and provides easily defined answers to the issues and challenges of life which are often very complex. Rather than concentrating on being culturally sensitive, the church should become sensitive to the formative power worship exercises over people. It should re-evaluate its idea of who constitutes the object of worship—the worshiper or God. It should abandon the attempt to rush God by skipping over what might be considered less attractive parts of the service in order to create a better performance. Let the church dedicate itself to discover anew the presence of God and to recognize that he alone is worthy of our worship.
Discuss This Topic with AI Worship CoachBrowse Structured Courses