Misplaced Priority In Worship
In many liturgical congregations, the church is viewed as an organization that exists for the liturgy. This author, writing from the perspective of the Orthodox tradition, offers a reminder that worship does not exist for its own sake, but as an expression of the reality of the church in relation to the world. His insights are useful to Christians of other traditions.
Today's liturgical crisis consists, first of all, in the mistaken concept of the function and place of worship in the church, in the profound metamorphosis in the understanding of worship in the mind of the church. Let us emphasize the fact that we are speaking here about something much more important than the misunderstanding of the texts, ceremonies, and language of divine service. We are speaking here about the whole approach to worship and its "experience." Worship—its structure, form, and content—remain what they were before and essentially what they have always been. In this sense it is right to speak of Orthodoxy's faithfulness to its liturgy. But to understand it and to use it are two different things. A discrepancy has appeared between the basic purpose of worship and the way it is understood. The membership of the church has simply not noticed this discrepancy, and worship actually excludes the possibility of this understanding. No matter how paradoxical it may sound, what obscures the meaning of worship is that it has become for the faithful an object of love, indeed almost the sole content of church life. Worship has ceased to be understood as a function of the church. On the contrary, the church herself has come to be understood as a function of worship. Christian worship, by its nature, structure, and content, is the revelation and realization by the church of her own real nature. And this nature is the new life in Christ—union in Christ with God the Holy Spirit, knowledge of the Truth, unity, love, grace, peace, salvation. In this sense the church cannot be equated or merged with worship; it is not the church which exists for the liturgy, but the liturgy for the church, for her welfare, for her growth into the full measure of the "stature of Christ" (Eph. 4:13, neb). Christ did not establish a society for the observance of worship, but rather the church as the way of salvation, as the new life of re-created mankind. This does not mean that worship is secondary to the church. On the contrary, it is inseparable from the church and without it there is no church. But this is because its purpose is to express, form, or realize the church—to be the source of that grace which always makes the church the church, the people of God, the body of Christ, "a chosen race [and] a royal priesthood" (1 Pet. 2:9, rsv). In fact, to the extent that the church exists not only as the living church today, but also the church handed down from the fathers, she embodies in worship her participation in God's kingdom, gives us a glimpse of the mystery of the age to come, expresses her love to the Lord who dwells within her, and her communion with the Holy Spirit. In this sense worship is the purpose of the church, but the purpose precisely of the church, as the highest and fullest expression and fulfillment of her nature: of her unity and love; of her knowledge of communion with God. But in the contemporary approach to worship there is the characteristic absence of an understanding of it as the expression of the church, as the creation of the church, and as the fulfillment of the church. The church has been merged with worship, has come to be understood as a sacramentally hierarchical institution existing for the performance of divine worship seen as sacred, supra-temporal, immutable mystery. The church is that which guarantees the objective character of this "sacred action," its reality so to speak, and in this sense the church in her sacramentally hierarchical structure is the instrument of this mystery and is subordinated to it. The church cannot express, create, and fulfill herself in it, because outside the mystery itself there is no church. There are separate believers, to a greater or lesser extent living individually by sacred contact with it, by the sanctification or nourishment received from it; there is also the "parish," i.e., an essentially lay organization, bound together by concern for the presence of this "sacred something"—for the church building and for the provision of the priesthood that it needs. But the individual believer, entering the church, does not feel he or she is a participant and celebrant of worship, does not know that in this act of worship he or she, along with the others who are constituting the church, is called to express the church as new life and to be transformed again into a member of the church. He or she has become an "object" of worship, celebrated for his or her "nourishment," so that the person may, as an individual, satisfy his or her "religious needs." In the same way the parish does not know that worship, as an expression of the parish, transforms it into the church, gives it those "dimensions" which it does not and cannot have naturally. It remains a limited human and only human community, living not as the church but by its own necessarily limited human interests. Having been turned into something "sacred in itself," worship has as it were "profaned" everything else in the church: her government becomes juridical and administrative in our eyes; her "material" life is strictly separated from spiritual content; and the hierarchy (having become the celebrants of the sacraments only, in which nobody sees the expression, creation, and fulfillment of the church) are naturally pushed out of the sphere of church administration, finances, and even teaching, since all these spheres have become profane and unsanctified. Now the sole content of the church's life, worship has ceased to be understood in its own real content, which is to be the expression, creation and fulfillment of the church. The overwhelming majority of Orthodox people have no interest in the meaning of worship. It is accepted and experienced in mystical and aesthetic but never "logical" categories. It moves the soul of the believer by its sacredness, by its mysteriousness, by its "other-worldliness." And everything that happens to fall within its orbit becomes overgrown with complicated symbolic explanations. It is characteristic that in this symbolism there is no symbolism of the church. Thus, people love to explain the divine liturgy as the depiction of the life of Christ. But who explains it as the expression of the life of the church, as the action by which she is eternally realized? Who ever sees that in this action she is not depicting the life of Christ before the congregation, but is manifesting, creating, and fulfilling herself as the body of Christ? The believer loves the ceremonies, symbols, the whole atmosphere of the church building, this familiar and precious nourishment for the soul, but his or her love does not long for understanding, because the purpose of the liturgy is thought of precisely as the bestowal of a spiritual experience, spiritual food. For the membership of the church, worship has ceased to be the church's self-evidencing. And finally, having become a liturgical society, existing in and for the sake of the worship experience, the membership of the church has become unable to understand that worship—as the expression, creation and fulfillment of the church—places the church before the face of the world, manifests her purpose in the world, the purpose of the people of God, set in the world with a gospel and a mission. Having ceased to be the expression of the church, worship has also ceased to be the expression of the church in relation to the world. It is no longer seen as the leaven which raises the loaf, as the love of God directed toward the world, as a witness to the kingdom of God, as the Good News of salvation, as new life. On the contrary, worship is experienced as a departure out of the world for a little while, as a "vent" or break in earthly existence, opened up for the inlet of grace.