Back to Media & Articles Library
downloadTheology & History

Philosophy Of Music In Free Church Worship

ByWorshipedia

Music in free worship is not bound to the text of worship itself, but appears here and there as separate, special, occasional, and incidental to the order of worship. This approach has led to a wide divergence or practice among churches.

It is almost impossible to arrive at a single philosophy for the music of free worship; the range of practice is extremely wide—from the quasiliturgical, to denominational formalism, to populist evangelicalism and fundamentalism. Theological paradigms vary widely, as do governance systems, ranging from centralized authority to localized sovereignty. Emphases among worship, evangelism, and outreach likewise differ from church to church. And finally, aesthetic philosophies range all the way from blatant utilitarianism (music's worth lies in its effectiveness) to idealism (music's effectiveness is subject to its intrinsic worth), and back to the middle (when worth and function are properly integrated, the music will be appropriate). Nonetheless, there are five biblical injunctions and precedents which broadly inform free worship musical practice:

1. Music making, both vocal and instrumental, is not an option but a commandment (Ps. 149:1—Sing [play] to the Lord).

2. Christians are commanded to make music first to God as an act of worship (Ps. 149:1—Sing/play to the Lord), then to each other (Eph. 5:19; Col. 3:16), and before the world (Ps. 57:9). 3. Even if music making were not a commandment, the person and work of God are of such magnitude that the redeemed cannot help but make music (Ps. 51:14). 4. All presentational types of music are acceptable: solo (I will sing/play), the trained ensemble (1 Chron 15; 16ff: temple choirs and instrumental ensembles), and the gathered congregation (temple worship, early church). 5. Newness and repetition are equally welcome (Ps. 33:3: Sing/play a new song; Ps. 137:3: Sing us one of the songs of Zion). Because of the wide variations in practice throughout the free churches, and since there are many ways in which they often borrow from current liturgical practice and retain memories from their several liturgical pasts, it is important to discuss the one difference that distinguishes the musical practice of the truly liturgical church from that of the free church. In a true liturgical context, musical practice is inseparable from celebrating the liturgy. Musical action, whatever its kind, does not precede, alternate with, bridge, or follow, other parts of the liturgy. There is no separately special, occasional, or incidental place for music. Instead, it is an indivisible part of a larger offering up—one facet of a larger confluence of languages (verbal, sensory, visual, iconographic, vestmental, and gestural) that comprise the whole. And the whole is not just the liturgy itself, but a comprehensive liturgical ethos of which everything comprising the life of the liturgical church is influenced. In this sense, musical practice is informed by thematic, calendrical, and contextual canons. While musical innovation and conservatism, singleness and repetition are equally possible, they are governed by the dynamics of the overall ethos. Liturgical music, by consequence, is probably less subject to whimsical change and the urges of pragmatism than many of its free-church counterparts. Distinctives and Issues of Free Worship Music Music Making Fulfills a Commandment. Music is not a luxury but a church-wide obligation from which no one is exempted. It is not something just reserved for the highly trained, nor does professional music- making earn a higher place before God. All is by faith, not by works or their quality, lest anyone should boast. Consequently, congregational song is at the center of free worship, in all its forms: hymns, gospel songs, and Scripture and praise choruses. The range of style and quality—and it is great—is often of less consequence than popularity, for heartfelt accessibility is of the essence. Music Making Is Primarily Godward. Singing to the Lord clarifies the principle (though, in practice, not always) that music making is first of all an act of worship—an offering. This concept further serves as a safeguard against the all-too-common tendency to judge audience response as the primary evaluative criterion for quality. Singing "to one another" reveals the didactic nature of song; yet while text is doing the teaching, melody still goes Godward ("making melody in your hearts to the Lord"). "To the world" is a primary aspect of free worship music, the strongly evangelistic tenor of which demands no little attention to musical outreach. The tripartite concept of "to the Lord," "to each other," and "to the world" is a complex concept and, historically speaking, not without its philosophical and practitional problems, two of which must be mentioned here: (1) overemphasis on utilitarianism at the expense of quality; (2) the attitude toward music as more of an "aid" to worship than an "act" of worship. The Redeemed Cannot Help But Make Music. Free church worship is centered in personal redemption. The gospel is for all. It is personally offered, personally received, personally celebrated, and personally spread. The grace of God, lavishly shown in Christ, is there for the faithful asking and taking. Communion with God, whether personal or corporate, is simple, uncluttered, and direct. The joy of the Lord translates quickly into song and the redeemed cannot help but take it up frequently, spontaneously, and above all, corporately. A musical worshiping church is therefore a musical witnessing church. The Appropriateness of All Types of Music. Little comment is necessary except for three matters. (1) The personal nature of free worship, the primacy of the spoken word (therefore of the pulpit), and the priesthood of all believers contribute, all too often, to an overemphasis on the individuality of music making. There is an ongoing tension between performance as showmanship, in contrast to humble musical servanthood. (2) Instrumental music by itself, outside of preludic, interludic, and postludic actions (not to be confused with the more intrinsic work of congregational, solo, and choral song) is often considered suspect or secondary because it has no text; Scripture, however, mandates prophesying (speaking up) on instruments themselves. (3) Free church music is eclectic and populist. If redemption is personal and the Good News is to be spread with all haste, this must mean that the church is a witnessing church and its music a witnessing music. Witnessing music must be accessible and "in the language of the people" or it might not witness. Consequently, the music of the culture(s) being witnessed to must be incorporated into the church's witness. The Balance of Newness and Repetition. The free church often ends up confusing novelty with newness, and rejecting it in favor of repetition and stylistic conservatism. Yet its doctrine of faithful sojourn and reckless abandon to the moving of the Spirit—often into uncharted territory—should allow for more musical innovation than is usually the case. In this matter, the free church is guilty of considerable distance between theology and practice.
Discuss This Topic with AI Worship CoachBrowse Structured Courses