downloadTheology & History
Philosophy Of Music In Roman Catholic Worship
Roman Catholic directives in music have restored a sung liturgy and developed a liturgical role for music. What is true in Catholic circles is also true among other liturgical communities. The goal of music in worship is the text of the liturgical service.
Before 1903, the philosophy of music in liturgical worship existed only in practice, in the making of music. The first official written statement on sacred music by an authority within a liturgical church was the papal letter Tra la Solicitudine in 1903. Written as a reform document to correct the abuses of operatic and romantic music of the two preceding centuries, Pope Pius X, who had been the choir director in the seminary in Venice, wanted to reinstate a chant style of music in the liturgy. Vatican Council At the Second Vatican Council in 1963-65, the leaders of the Catholic church, with support from all the liturgical churches, affirmed that "full, conscious, and active participation" of the faithful was the aim of the liturgical renewal and should be considered before all else. Specific directives were given to encourage active participation, including, for the Catholic church, the use of vernacular languages throughout the world. In regard to sacred music, an entire chapter (VI) of the Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy put forth a series of directions that codified some of the philosophical principles for sacred music. Here is a summary of the main points of this document. 1. Sacred music is to be considered the more holy in proportion as it is more closely connected with the liturgical action, whether it adds delight to prayer, fosters unity of minds, or confers greater solemnity upon the sacred rites. The church approves of all forms of true art having the needed qualities and admits them into divine worship (par. #112). 2. Liturgical worship is given a more noble form when it is celebrated solemnly in song (par. #113). 3. Repertoire from the past (the treasury of sacred music) is to be preserved and fostered. Choirs are to be promoted, and the whole body of the faithful must be able to participate (par. #114). 4. Education in music by well trained teachers is encouraged in seminaries, institutes of higher learning, and for composers and singers (par. #115). 5. "The Roman Catholic Church acknowledges Gregorian chant as specially suited to the Roman liturgy; therefore, other things being equal, it should be given pride of place in liturgical services. But other kinds of sacred music, especially polyphony, are by no means excluded from liturgical celebrations" (par. #116). 6. Religious singing by the people is to be skillfully fostered, so that in religious prayer the voices of the faithful may ring out (par. #118). 7. Throughout the world, a suitable place is to be given to music which reflects the diversity of cultures and place. This native music should lead people toward a central unity and reflect the diversity by adapting worship to the native situation (par. #119). 8. In the Latin church, the pipe organ is to be held in high esteem. But other instruments suitable for worship may be used (par. #120). 9. Composers are encouraged to develop new music appropriate to the liturgy, not confining themselves to works which can be sung only by large choirs, but providing also for the needs of small choirs and for the active participation of the entire assembly of the faithful. The texts should be chiefly drawn from Scripture and liturgical sources. Current Practice Since the Second Vatican Council (1965–present), the development in sacred music for liturgical worship has been explosive and the philosophy along with it. Every major denomination has issued a revised hymnal, reflecting various stages of development. Some contain sexist language; others incorporate inclusive language. In 1980, an International Study Group, Universa Laus, issued a statement on the philosophy of music in liturgical worship. And throughout this period, The National Association of Pastoral Musicians has reflected the development of the philosophy of church music in the United States, based on the practice of its members. Here are five key principles. 1. Musical liturgy is normative. In the tradition of liturgical worship, the liturgy is supposed to be sung or cantillated. A spoken text is an aberration in liturgical worship. Music, therefore, is the handmaid of the text (words) and the text is already given—e.g., Lord, have mercy; Glory to God; Holy; Psalm texts, etc. 2. The assembly is the primary musician. All others who take a musical role assist the assembly's worshiping role. 3. Music supports a liturgical function. Each section of the liturgy has a ritual function—e.g., procession, blessing, acclamation, etc.—and the role of the music is to enrich that ritual function. When music calls attention to itself, it distracts from the ritual function. 4. Liturgical prayer through music is balanced between performance and participation. Too much exclusive attention to either performance or participation is detrimental to prayer; it is equally true that too little attention to liturgical prayer itself is also detrimental. 5. Liturgical music is a unique art form. In the historical development of music, a musical form for specific use in the liturgy developed first, followed by choral music, symphonic and operatic. Some of the early stages of all of these forms took place first in church, using church texts. But in hindsight, the liturgical movement has judged that, while this musical development was important for music in general, it was detrimental to the basic philosophy of musical liturgy. Musical liturgy is more like a folk art form because of the diversity of assemblies using it—from small to large, from ethnic based to plural forms, etc. However, liturgical music is a true art form, unique because the principle instrument is the singing assembly. Trends for the Future Current trends would indicate that the development of music in liturgical worship will continue into the future. For this development to take place, it will require dropping some of the practices which have recently developed and, of course, developing new practices. Many of these trends are already apparent and are beginning to redefine the philosophy of church music in practice. From: To: Hymnody Service music Singing thematically Singing liturgically Singing everything, even poorly Singing less, but well Sacred treasure Pastoral music Praise only Adoration/thanksgiving/petition Song leaders Cantors Choirs More choirs Parish musician Musician/liturgist Central leadership Pastoral leadership Hymnody is not native to the Roman liturgy. It entered into the Mass when musicians were seeking quality music immediately after permission was given to sing in the vernacular. More emphasis is now being placed on "service" music, or singing the given text of the Mass. The principles for selecting repertoire are changing from the misconceived idea that the Scripture readings produced a "theme" for the Mass and therefore the music should reflect this theme. Today, most musicians have abandoned this false principle and have a better understanding of the liturgical year. With the first flush of enthusiasm following the Second Vatican Council, some amateur musicians were insisting, "Sing anything, just sing." As congregational participation has faced its limitations, musicians are selecting the repertoire more carefully and encourage singing only what can be done well. Art music is giving way to music which functions in and with the liturgical requirements. Only slowly have musicians discovered the functional aspects of liturgical worship and the important role which music plays in it. Music carries a variety of prayerful sentiments, more than simply praise. More musicians are discovering the importance of music in carrying the diversity of positions which human beings hold in relationship to God, from adoration and supplication to praise and thanksgiving. The musicians themselves are changing; no longer seeing themselves as simply leaders of song, but developing their role as liturgical ministers. As parishes are financing full time musicians, many are becoming liturgists responsible for planning the entire liturgical celebration and assisting in the "performance" aspect of all the liturgical arts, including drama, movement, visual arts, etc. The greatest overarching influence on church music is the relationship between the clergy and musician, which should be developed and nourished through regular meetings and open communication. The philosophy of music in liturgical worship exists in these two worlds: the theoretical world of our documents and directives, and, simultaneously, in the practical world of parish life. It has always existed in these two worlds, and it will continue to exist in these two worlds. Hopefully, a working knowledge of this tension will serve to produce better liturgical music in our parishes.