Principle Seven: Worship Makes Effective Use Of God's Creative Gifts
The Bible envisions worship as an offering of the entire person in living sacrifice to the Lord. Creative and thoughtful use of space and art, as well as attention to the traditional church calendar, combine to make worship an experience that involves body, soul, and spirit.
Worship Involves the Whole Person Worship is an activity that includes every aspect of the human awareness: heart and mind, senses and intellect. St. Paul bids us, "offer your bodies as living sacrifices, holy and pleasing to God—this is your spiritual act of worship" (Rom. 12:1). We can see how he is using the word "spiritual" here: not in contrast to the physical but rather as a quality of worship that includes the physical and ultimately transcends it. Nothing in the human experience lies outside the scope of true Christian worship. For too long, at least in the West, and perhaps especially among the Protestant churches, worship has been an activity primarily of the mind. It has been reduced to a process of edifying the mind and informing the intellect. Yet the scriptural commandments of Old and New Testaments alike are as all-embracing as they possibly can be: to love God with all our heart and soul, mind, body, passions, and strength. We need to take the concept of corporate worship even further and see our worship not only as an activity involving the whole body of Christ and all its members but also as an activity involving the whole human body—mind, heart, and spirit. It is quite clear that we cannot and must not exclude the body with all its senses in the totally involving activity of worship. The use of the body is an outward and visible sign of the intentions of the heart and mind, as every ballet dancer and actor knows—or forgets at his or her peril. But, at a more mundane level, we also know that the use of the body for self-expression is true in the ordinary affairs of everyday life. If I am conducting an interview, the position of my body will indicate the level at which I intend to conduct that interview and will also say something of my relationship with the person I am interviewing. If I remain seated, behind a desk, and you are compelled to remain standing, I am implying that you are my inferior and you may well be on the carpet! If on the other hand you are seated and suddenly I stand up and begin to walk up and down the room, there is the chance that I shall be remonstrating and seeking to make a point or even to deliver myself of some lecture upon a topic that has become the burden of my soul. But if I come from behind the desk and pull up an armchair alongside you, the ice is broken and confidence and cordiality would be the name of the game. Truth to tell, the whole of our life is shot through with ceremonials, often unconsciously, but frequently consciously (as at dinner parties). So it would be a strange fragmentation if, when we expressed ourselves before God, we suddenly affected a distaste for ceremonials. Time, Art, and Space Enhance Worship Still raging today is an age-old debate that has divided Christians throughout the centuries—just how much and to what extent the use of art forms is permissible in worship. The Orthodox position is founded on the Old Testament. These worshipers point to the elaborate artistic beauty of the tabernacle and the temple. If God permitted our senses to be involved in worship in the Old Testament, they ask, why would he forbid it in the New Testament? They also cite the example of the Incarnation. Look, they say, God became a man—a human, visible, material, sensual person. If God can communicate himself to us through a created body, why can't we respond similarly to him through color, sound, movement, smell, touch, and sight? On the other side of the issue, Protestants draw their position from the second commandment: "You shall not make for yourself an idol in the form of anything in the heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God" (Exod. 20:4–5). They interpret these words as a command against the use of any icons, frescoes, or statues that depict heavenly images. Yet, many Protestants acknowledge that this verse does not specifically deny or forbid the use of such items as candles, incense, vestments, processions, musical instruments, choirs, stained glass windows, door and furniture carvings, artistically designed pulpits, tables, or baptismal fonts. Why, then, do we Protestants have such plain settings for our worship? The issue comes down to a difference of opinion articulated during the sixteenth-century Reformation by John Calvin on the one hand and Martin Luther and the Anglicans on the other. Luther and the Anglicans believed that whatever is not explicitly rejected by the Scripture may be used in worship. Consequently, they were free to use the ceremonial quite liberally. But Calvin believed that only that which is explicitly taught in the New Testament is permissible in worship. Since the New Testament says nothing pro or con about the use of art in worship, Calvinists and their successors were not free to employ the arts as means of expressing worship to almighty God. We cannot hope to solve an age-old controversy here. So, let it be sufficient to ask the Protestant community for a second consideration of some of the least controversial issues related to using the arts in worship—arts such as music, drama, dance, space, and color. We are not arguing that art is necessary for worship. Certainly we can worship God anywhere and under any conditions. To insist that art is necessary for worship is to commit aesthetic heresy. Such insistence makes art an idol, an object of our worship. On the other hand, to insist that art is a hindrance to worship is equally dangerous. It denies that the material creation is a worthy vehicle through which God can communicate with us and we with him. Ultimately it denies the Incarnation, for it was in human, material flesh that God became present to us in Jesus Christ. It is evident that the architecture of our church is shaped by our concept of worship; the architecture, in turn, shapes our experience of worship. It is the function of space to foster rather than hinder congregational participation. Unfortunately, the typical Protestant church employs a very closed use of space. The aisles are often narrow and the pews are situated in a style similar to that of the lecture hall. This arrangement, combined with a dominant pulpit, restricts the congregation's involvement in worship. There is very little space for musical processions, for artistic expression, for drama, or for dance. When I am in this kind of space, I always feel that my natural inhibitions are being supported and a leader-dominated worship is being affirmed. Where space is used to enhance their interrelationship, people sustain each other. We feel more a part of the body of Christ in that kind of place. But, when all we see is the back of someone's head, when there is no eye contact with other people, our sense of the unity of the body of Christ is impaired. In a semicircle seating or a seating where two sides face each other, the sense of community is stronger. In my experience I have been edified and moved to deeper worship by observing the involvement of other people in worship. I have seen people communicate the joy of worship through their faces and gestures. For me, watching someone sing enthusiastically or prayerfully or humbly is a moving experience. Seeing others bow and kneel in prayer or watching someone reverently receiving the bread and wine increases my own participation in the community action of worship.