downloadTheology & History
Recovering Symbolism In Worship
The concern of this article is to focus on symbolism as a medium through which the gospel of reconciliation may be communicated within the Christian community through worship.
The Place of Symbolism in Worship It is generally recognized that a symbol both points beyond itself and participates in that which it symbolizes. In this sense the church itself is a symbol of the kingdom. It is not the kingdom itself, but it points to the kingdom and participates in the kingdom. The church is the presence of the kingdom in the world. The church is the visible expression of the restored creation. It is not a mere ghostlike apparition but a visible, tangible society of people who have been born into the kingdom and whose new lives are taking shape in the midst of the world. This society of people, bound as they are by time, space, and history, are nevertheless the people of the "?new heavens and the new earth.?" For this reason, the church's life and worship in this world has symbolic significance, both to itself and to the world. The fact that the church is a symbol illustrates the significance of symbols. Therefore when we consider the function of symbols in worship as a means of communicating the Christian faith, we must not treat them as mere psychological creations but as images of an ultimate reality. The realm of the supernatural is as real as the natural. Thus, a symbol in the natural world corresponds to a reality of the supernatural world. The church in the world corresponds to the church in the mind of God. The worship of the church joins worship in the heavens. The nature of faith itself demands the transformation of supernatural concepts into visible images and symbols. Because no finite language can fully and completely express supernatural truth adequately, biblical religion and the church in history has always relied on symbolism as a means of communicating that which transcends the realm of the finite. The language of faith has always, therefore, been a language of symbols (see Jean Danielow, S.J., Primitive Christian Symbols [Baltimore: Helicon Press, 1964]; and Gustav Aulén, The Drama and the Symbols [Philadelphia: Fortress, 1970]). A glance at the history of worship suggests that it has only been recently, and especially within the Protestant Christian community, that symbolic communication has fallen into disuse. The rise of the printed page in the sixteenth century replaced the symbolic form of communication with the written word. The chief form of communication in the West, until the technological developments of the twentieth century, have been reading and writing. The invention of radio, however, signaled a shift toward the recovery of other senses in communication. Sensory communication has accelerated with the introduction of television and new advertising techniques. As people become more and more dependent on the visual means of communication, reading and writing skills will go into decline and the impact of the visual will assume greater proportions. This means it is particularly important for the church to once again recapture the use of symbolism as a means of communication. This is especially incumbent upon Protestants, whose reform was sparked and spread by the revolution introduced by the Gutenberg press. Arguments for the Recovery of Symbolism in Worship There is an urgent need to recover the use of symbolism in the church. First, there has been a loss of the use of symbolism in worship among most Protestants. Protestants are accustomed to simple and straightforward language. The use of imagery, symbols, and even subtle language is relatively unknown among many Protestants who thoughtlessly have locked themselves into discursive expression as the preferable, if not the only, form of worship. One reason why evangelicals prefer verbal communication has to do with their view of the Bible. They see the Bible as a book of words. It is God's written revelation. This emphasis on the written words of Scripture coupled with an attitude of neglect toward the symbolic forms of communication (which constitute a large portion of Scripture) are at the root of the neglect of the symbolic in worship. Therefore, the emphasis falls on words and cognitive understanding in communication. While words and objective understanding play an important part in communication and should not be denied, there is nevertheless another dimension of communication that needs further exploration—symbolism. Symbolic communication is affirmed in the Scriptures. Scripture is filled with visions, dreams, imagery, and apocalyptic material. A second reason to recover symbolism is found in the recognition that persons are symbolic creatures. For example, recent research in psychology, especially that branch which attempts to understand the neural organization of the human mind, has concluded that the brain functions differently in the right and left hemispheres. The left hemisphere appears to specialize in verbal functions, and right hemisphere centers on spatial functions and other nonverbal skills. This is the concern of Stephen G. Meyer in an article entitled "?Neuropsychology and Worship.?" He sets out to relate the findings of neural investigation to the experience of worship (Stephen G. Meyer, "?Neuropsychology and Worship,?" Journal of Psychology and Theology [Fall 1975], 281–89). His argument, which begins with Scripture, is that (1) while Scripture is verbal, the material it communicates is based on a variety of communication models, ranging from discursive expression to highly apocalyptic language to poetic discourse; (2) although Christianity is grounded on reason, illustrated by Paul's reasoning from the Scriptures in the synagogue (see Acts 17:2) or Peter's insisting that Christians give "?an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have .…?" (1 Pet. 3:15), there are nevertheless "?definitive confrontations between God and humans where there is concurrent use of vision and word?" (Meyer, 285). Meyer cites the examples of Ezekiel, Job, and John (Revelation) and concludes, "?While the Bible presents the Christian faith as a rational faith, the rationale is built on symbols which outline its structure?" (Meyer, 286). Rollo May argues that the loss of symbols constitutes one of humanity's chief difficulties. When people have no symbols to identify and illustrate the meaning of life, they cannot transcend the crises of life. Hunger, war, death, unemployment, disease, and the other horrors that confront civilization on a daily basis seem to be the sum and substance of life. Without signs or symbols in this world to show people another world or a means of coping with the trials and strains of this world, people have nowhere to turn but to despair and absurdity. A third reason to recover symbolism in worship is rooted in the recognition that symbolism is at the very center of life itself. The celebrations of birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, marriages, funerals, and the like are all ways of acting out the meaning of things that words alone fail to convey. Likewise the great drama of the world as expressed in Scripture, from the Fall to the restoration of humanity in Jesus Christ, ought to be communicated not only in words but in the actions of the church. Symbolic communication in the church is a valid means of communicating truths of the Christian faith. The reenactment of the birth of Christ, the sorrow over his death, the joy of his resurrection, and the power of Pentecost cannot be completely nor adequately communicated through words alone. If the human brain is oriented toward spatial as well as verbal communication, then Christian worship must not neglect the symbolic, nonverbal, and ritualistic means of communication. Recovering Symbolism in Worship In Isaiah 6 and again in Revelation 4, the creatures of God are worshiping God. Both Isaiah and John were smitten with the holiness of God and heard the creatures who surrounded the throne cry, "?Holy, holy, holy, /is the Lord God Almighty, /who was, and is, and is to come?" (Rev. 4:8, cf. Isa. 6:3). A fascinating feature about this vision is the symbolism that surrounded God on the throne. Isaiah saw God "?seated on a throne, high and exalted, and the train of his robe filled the temple. Above him were seraphs, each with six wings: With two wings they covered their faces, with two they covered their feet, and with two they were flying?" (Isa. 6:1–2). John's description is more elaborate:And the one who sat there had the appearance of jasper and carnelian. A rainbow, resembling an emerald, encircled the throne. Surrounding the throne were twenty-four other thrones, and seated on them were twenty-four elders. They were dressed in white and had crowns of gold on their heads. From the throne came flashes of lightning, rumblings and peals of thunder. Before the throne, seven lamps were blazing. These are the seven spirits of God. Also before the throne there was what looked like a sea of glass, clear as crystal .… (Rev. 4:3–6).
The important features of these visions are the visual images that speak to the greatness of God. All creatures of God, including creation itself, fall before God to ascribe power and glory. In both the Old and New Testaments three reasons are given why God's people should be at worship. They are (1) because God created all things (see Exod. 20:11 and Rev. 4:11); (2) because God has redeemed a people (see Deut. 5:15 and Rev. 5:9); and (3) because God has entered into covenant community with his people (see Exod. 24:3–8 and Rev. 5:10). The designation of the people of God in both the Old Testament (Q'hal) and the New Testament (ecclesia) has as its root meaning the people who are gathered for worship. The public worship of the church is therefore a corporate act in which the church as the covenant community rehearses both who God is and what God has done. In this way the church ascribes worth to God and gives God the glory. Consequently we must ask what principles should guide the restoration of symbolism in our worship? I will mention four. First, it will be necessary to recognize that earthly worship is modeled after a heavenly pattern. The visions of Isaiah and John affirm and do not negate the use of symbolism in worship. Obviously it is impossible and not advisable to literally reproduce the elements of their visions. On the other hand, a refusal to incorporate visual symbols in worship is a resistance by the earthly church to join the heavenly hosts in ascribing worth to God. But how may the church on earth enter into visual, symbolic worship? A church building itself may represent the heavenlies while the chancel represents the throne of God. In this context the ministers, the choir, and the congregation envision themselves as the servants of God who gather around the throne to proclaim God's redemptive act. The aesthetic setting in which this takes place could range all the way from a Byzantine cathedral to a simple chapel. The thing of ultimate importance is not the gold and glitter, but the triggering of the worshipers' imaginations and spirits through the visual and symbolic setting. Second, it is important to recover worship as an action. It is something we do—not something done to us. The visions given in Isaiah and Revelation indicate that worshipers are not merely passive observers. They were involved in doing something. In the account of John, the creatures did not rest "?day or night,?" the elders "?[fell] down before him,?" and "?cast their crowns before the throne?" (Rev. 4:8,10, nkjv). Worship involves an active response of the worshiper. In the history of Christian worship there has been a strong emphasis on what the worshiper does. In the Catholic and Orthodox traditions the worshiper genuflects, kneels, sings numerous responses, bows, says "?amen?" at the end of the prayers, walks forward for Communion, smells the incense, hears the bells, sees the Host, and passes the kiss of peace. Charismatic worship is also quite active. Charismatics raise their hands, speak in tongues, interpret, prophesy, sing in the Spirit, and sometimes dance spontaneously. In this sense the Catholics, the Orthodox, the charismatics, and others who stress the involvement of the whole person in worship are using a greater variety of symbolic actions than those who merely sit and expect to be challenged or filled. Third, we cannot neglect time, space, and history as elements of worship. There is a timeless character to the worship described by Isaiah and John. Although worship takes place in time, space, and history, the church recognizes that these elements have an eternal character. For example, time has always been interpreted in relationship to the coming of Christ, to his life and ministry, to his death and resurrection, to the coming of the Holy Spirit in the life of the church, and to the second coming of Christ. These events, all of which are historical, are gathered up into the liturgy of the church and reenacted symbolically. Because space also belongs to the Lord by virtue of creation and redemption, the redeemed nature of space may be demonstrated in the architectural arrangement of the building (both inside and outside). These forms of communication played an important part in the witness of the ancient church. A study of the development of the church year, of the feasts and festivals that celebrated the great drama of Christ's birth, death, and resurrection, and the coming of the Holy Spirit, as well as an examination of the redemptive understanding of art and architecture need to be revived in this age of the return to the visual. Fourth, we must always keep in mind that worship is a learned art. The idea that worship is instantaneous, spontaneous, and natural betrays our lack of understanding. We are more than willing to agree that a successful musician, artist, dramatist, salesman, doctor, teacher, lawyer, carpenter, or homemaker must learn the art of doing his or her profession right! Yet when it comes to the Christian faith, to worship, and to the communication of Christian truths, we somehow feel that it should all fall into place naturally without any effort on our part. For this reason it is important to emphasize both the learned and artistic nature of worship. The process by which it has been learned is historical. The interested reader will want to examine various church liturgies for special holy days such as Christmas, Easter, and Pentecost. Symbolism can be seen also in the vestments, architecture, and music of the church. Each of these areas will provide additional ideas for recovering symbolism in the contemporary church.