Back to Media & Articles Library
downloadTheology & HistoryWorship Leading

Ritual In Pastoral Care

ByKenneth R. Mitchell

The author gives a concise definition of ritual, its meaning and origin, and looks at the pastoral care aspects of liturgy, stating that "?for many Christians, the sacraments are the primary meeting place of ritual and pastoral care.?" He concludes with a look at the use of ritual prayer in the traditional one-on-one counseling relationship.

Many serious students of pastoral care, and of ritual, find any positive relationship between the two, dubious at best. To begin a consideration of ritual pastoral care, therefore, we need to remember the recent nature of these mutual suspicions. Until about fifty years ago, rituals of church life were closely intertwined with pastoral care. The history of pastoral care paralleled the history of ritual (it could even be said that at times it was the history of ritual), for pastoral care was expressed, more often than not, in ritualized forms. After the apostolic era, pastoral response to critical life situations took on, in many case, a ritualized and formal character; pastoral responses to human situations were often judged appropriate or inappropriate by how faithfully they clove to established forms. That pattern held sway for much of Christian history. (John T. McNeill's monumental History of the Cure of Souls [New York: Harper, 1951] makes the shift from the personal to the formal in pastoral care very clear. But the shift from personal to formal did not originate with Christianity.) The last half-century has seen a major change, traceable to at least three influences. Culturally, there has been a growing mistrust of forms and of the authority they appear to represent. In psychological theory, Freud and his followers linked ritual to obsessional neuroses—although ritualized practices were and are clearly visible in many aspects of psychoanalytically-oriented treatment. In religious practice, in pastoral care theory, and especially in clinical pastoral education, there has grown up an insistence that ritual ignores the particular, in favor of the general; and that the use of rituals permits ministers to avoid dealing with difficult interpersonal situations. In the Presbyterian seminary I attended, pastoral care was taught as a series of formalized behaviors. In situation A, the pastor should engage in activity A; in situation B use B, and so on through the catalogue of human crises. I saw only a few years later that the forms—pastoral care rituals, worship rituals, and even formal clerical clothing—so valued in the Department of Practical Theology at that seminary were avoided and even despised by those most deeply grounded in pastoral care and counseling. Today specialists in pastoral care, in fact, present no consistent picture in terms of the use of ritual. At a recent conference among such specialists, I spoke with a pastoral counselor who rigorously refused to conduct worship in any such setting, where one of his clients might be attending worship. In addition, I spoke with another who used ritual both in church worship services and in her counseling practice. Pastoral care specialists have been lax in examining the relationship between pastoral care and ritual in a disciplined way. (A significant and exciting exception is Elaine Ramshaw's Ritual and Pastoral [Philadelphia, Pa.: Fortress, 1987].) There is, however, a growing consciousness that pastoral care and church ritual are far more deeply related to each other than has been ordinarily assumed. Paul W. Pruyser, the late psychologist of religion, who for many years directed the Department of Education at the Menninger Foundation, was troubled by the disuse of ritual in church life. In an essay written for a 1969 Festschrift in honor of Seward Hiltner, Pruyser discussed a particular aspect of ritual—benedictions and blessings—in his typically pungent style:

Over the years, in attending worship services, I had gradually become accustomed to ministers terminating their services with a rushed and hardly audible benediction, uttered on the way out from the back of the sanctuary where nobody could see them. And if the benediction was pronounced from the pulpit, audibly and visibly, the spectacle for the beholders was often little more than a slovenly gesture, consisting of only one arm, raised half-heartedly and only half-way up, against the force of gravity to which that poor limb would quickly succumb again. [This experience is evidence] that there has been a steady decay in Protestantism of once powerful and wholesome symbols, or … the replacement of symbols by mere emblems. (Paul W. Pruyser, "?The Master Hand: Psychological Notes on Pastoral Blessing,?" in The New Shape of Pastoral Theology, ed. William B. Oglesby [New York: Abingdon, 1969], 353.)

Pruyser saw, more clearly than many of his contemporaries, the intimate, subtle relationship between pastoral care and ritual. In tracing that relationship, our first task is to understand more clearly the nature of ritual. The Nature of Ritual

[A ritual is] an ordered or patterned sequence of interpersonal behavior, often occurring in connection with a particular event or circumstance, performed in the same (or a very similar) way each time it occurs, sometimes embodying a reference to a historical event, and symbolizing—pointing beyond itself to—a value or belief commonly held by the individuals or groups who perform it.

This definition encompasses a wide variety of religious and nonreligious behaviors, from the "?Minnesota farewells?" affectionately lampooned by Garrison Keillor to the most formal religious ceremonies. It includes the ways a particular family celebrates holidays, birthdays, and anniversaries. It includes such sacramental gestures as the laying on of hands at an ordination or in the giving of a blessing, the joining of the hands of a marrying couple, or the breaking of the bread at a eucharistic celebration. It excludes certain behaviors which, though sometimes called ritualistic, grow out of a particular person's need for defense against unwelcome experience (e.g., the "?ritualized?" counting or handwashing engaged in by people suffering from compulsive disorders). In church bodies with a strong liturgical consciousness, the proper performance of ritual may be carefully defined and described by the church and great value may be placed on performing the ritual properly. In other churches, rituals are equally present, but tend to be considered informal or even casual, rather than formally prescribed. Even such supposedly informal rituals tend to have considerable power, however; and those who develop them will often resist very vigorously any attempt to alter them. Those who deviate may suffer unpleasant social consequences. Any group of people regularly interacting with each other tends to attach to rituals feelings that, to an outsider, seem far more intense than an objective evaluation would warrant. Anthropologist Edward T. Hall calls this formal behavior, behavior based on an apparent assumption that there is no other way to do things (Edward T. Hall, The Silent Language [New York: Doubleday, 1959]). Functions or Meanings of Ritual Rituals provide at least three things felt by those who participate in them to be valuable. (1) They offer a sense of identity, of "?we-ness?" which cements the bonds among members of a particular group. People, who can say of themselves that "?we do things this way,?" have a means of saying who they are and what they hold in common. The traditions of families, the liturgies of churches, and the customs of nations and ethnic groups, all serve this function. (2) Rituals offer to participants a sense of living in a regular, reliable, trustworthy world. The Christmas decorations are put away with the confidence that these same ornaments and wreaths will be used to decorate the house and the tree, next year. (In many families, the ornaments are put away on the same day each year, perhaps New Year's Day or Epiphany). (3) Rituals in many cases symbolize a deeply felt reality, a truth about God, self, or life. They take on a kind of life from that reality. Theologian Paul Tillich argued that rituals, like all symbols, participate in the reality of that which they symbolize, and die if the reality behind them dies. The Formation of Rituals Any piece of behavior which someone finds useful, valuable, or even merely pleasant may be "?nominated?" to become a ritual, but the process is not as conscious as the word nominated might suggest. At first, it may be repeated merely because it has been experienced as appropriate, meaningful, or simply gratifying. Through repetition, the behavior takes on power. Meanings are often added by accretion, collecting over the years. Rituals formed in this way often bypass conscious processes of formation, and (partly because the process is kept out of conscious awareness) take on considerable psychological power. Here the meaning of ritual resembles the function of religion as C. G. Jung saw it: to allow people to be in touch with their in most depths without being overwhelmed by them. There are other processes of formation. It is possible to invent a ritual by consciously seeking ways of symbolizing a felt reality. Rapid changes in a society and its patterns of relationship may prompt people to create rituals that express, or help to manage, feelings arising in reaction to the changes. Such conscious inventions are attempts to perform a function, which simply accrues or develops in a less intentional process. In the mid-1970s a committee of the United Methodist Church wrestled with issues of change and produced a book called Ritual in a New Day: An Invitation (Alternate Rituals Editorial Committee of the Board of Discipleship of the United Methodist Church, Ritual in a New Day: An Invitation [New York: Abingdon, 1976]). It included rituals for the dying, for the ending of marriages, and for other beginnings and endings. The strength of the book lay in its approach to previously uncharted areas; its weakness lay in its wordiness. It is characteristic that many consciously invented rituals, including those in the Methodist book, place heavy reliance on the spoken word. Other behaviors are not entirely omitted; one divorce ritual includes removing a wedding ring from the divorcing woman's left hand and placing it on the ring finger of the right hand, thus making the ring "?reconsecrated to her freedom?" (Ritual in a New Day, 92). But the principal reliance is on words; and all too often, the carefully chosen words lack the rhetorical power which frequently seems to come with the words of a ritual that has gradually evolved. (The heavy reliance on words in consciously constructed ritual often narrows or forces the meaning of the ritual.) In some cases, new conditions and changed circumstances have been well-served by the adaptation and application of an already existing ritual originally evolved for a somewhat different purpose. Such rituals tend to have the emotional power of the original, but they run the risk of making misstatements about the nature of the situation to which they are being applied. If a ritual has been used in one situation and is now applied to another, participants tend to regard this new situation as a mere variant of the first, rather than as something new and different. Rituals also take on a life of their own, in a process closely akin to what Gordon Allport called "?functional autonomy.?" This may mean that the ritual in question becomes so far removed from its origins that many would call it dead. Long after a ritual has ceased to fulfill the third function cited earlier, it may still fulfill the first two functions. Perhaps one might say that even when theologically dead in Tillich's sense, a ritual may for a time remain alive psychologically. Ritual and Pathology Many psychotherapists tend to hold ritual of any kind in contempt. Much psychoanalytic thought has adopted Freud's old assertion that there is a profound connection between obsessional states of mind and religious ritual. Therapists of various persuasions have expressed suspicion of ritual, warning us to be wary of any behavior on our own part that we regularly repeat. They have a valid point; many ritual behaviors can be used as defenses. At the same time, most therapies and therapists have developed rituals of their own, differing from locale to locale and from one theoretical approach to another. American psychoanalysts tend to avoid the "?handshaking ritual?" prevalent in our society, while those in Europe tend to shake hands formally with analysts at each session. The ritualistic aspects of analytic meeting rooms, with their "?icons of the saints,?" have frequently been notified. So has the highly stylized language that therapists tend to use to identify members of their own "?clubs.?" In one center where family systems theory is dominant, the use of the word transference is ritualistically avoided. Psychotherapists often use ritual settings, ritualized language, and even ritualized postures and body movements—largely to keep anxiety at a minimum. Ritual is not in itself anti-therapeutic. However, using it unconsciously, using it without knowing why one is using it, or using it as a means of exercising power and control can all be anti-therapeutic. Therapists' clients will often ascribe some kind of power to any ritualized behavior; and it is quite possible for a therapist to use rituals of some kind to take the edge off the therapists' own feelings of powerlessness or insecurity, at some cost to the client. It is clear that some uses of ritual have a pathological basis. Rituals do in some ways serve as defenses against unwanted experience. Defenses, however, are not in themselves pathological, and often serve quite positive purposes. It becomes pathological when defenses are misused or overused. Pastoral Care Aspects of Liturgy Many aspects of familiar liturgies have particular meaning for pastoral care. Specialists tend to be more interested in the way ritual may be used in pastoral care and counseling, but an approach "?from the other direction?" may be more important to parish pastors. Liturgy in General. Calls to worship, assurances of pardon or absolution, benedictions, and other common elements in a worship service are likely to evoke a deep response from worshipers, even when they are not consciously aware of it. Not long ago, a member of a congregation returned to Sunday morning worship after having been hospitalized for a major heart attack. After the service, she said to the minister, "?The opening hymn was wonderful! Everybody sang so enthusiastically, and I felt like I could really lift up my heart and rejoice.?" The minister properly understood her comment to mean that pastoral care had been extended to this woman through the choice and singing of the hymn. Among the great figures of the past half-century in pastoral care and counseling, Seward Hiltner was for many years the principal articulator of contemporary pastoral theology. One of his legacies—perhaps his greatest—is his perspectival approach, which affirms that there is no such thing as an instance of pastoral work that has only one meaning (Seward Hiltner, Preface to Pastoral Theology [New York: Abingdon, 1959]). All pastoral care among Christians involves, however subtly, a proclamation of the gospel; pastoral care among Jews involves, however subtly, an exposition of Torah. What concerns us here is the way a "?shepherding?" perspective shows up in rituals primarily intended for some other purpose. The word shepherding has been controversial ever since Hiltner decided to use it. Many resent the implications of stupidity or willingness to be part of a herd, which they believe they see in the word. Hiltner's original choice was of course not predicated on those implications but upon biblical imagery and upon the caring, self-giving qualities long associated with such imagery. But the negative implications of the metaphor are undeniable. Consider again Paul Pruyser's comments upon the way a benediction is delivered. Liturgical theology and pastoral theology are likely to come to similar conclusions about such gestures. In some churches, one can see a benediction delivered with hands at waist height, palms turned upward. In the history of liturgical theology that gesture is a beseeching attitude, the posture used for a prayer of petition. It is quite different from the classical posture for blessing advocated by Pruyser, in which it is clear that the "?blesser?" is giving something to someone. From the point of view of liturgical theology, the petition gesture does not say that the leader is delivering a blessing. The pastoral theologian would probably conclude that the minister has rejected the idea of delivering a blessing in the first place. Contained in that shift is a profound reshaping of the understanding of the nature of ministry. As William Willimon has pointed out, "?every element of the worship service has some potential use as pastoral care?" (Worship as Pastoral Care [Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1979]). Sermons may grow out of particular pastoral concerns. (When psychologist Harry Levinson worked at the Menninger Foundation, he defined a pastoral sermon as one which adequately described a hurt, put a label on it, and suggested clearly what could be done about it. From a Christian perspective, one might alter that slightly to include what God has already done about it.) Pastoral prayers may come to grips with issues and feelings. Postures, gestures, and ways of handling sacraments may touch upon issues too deep for words. Sacraments. For many Christians, the sacraments are the primary meeting place of ritual and pastoral care. Many sacraments are symbolic reenactments of some event in the life and ministry of Jesus. (I use the term sacrament also to include what in various denominations are otherwise called "?sacramentals?" or "?ordinances.?") Although words accompany and to some extent give specific meanings to sacramental acts, sacraments convey meanings "?too deep for words.?" One act may "?contain?" a very wide variety of meanings simultaneously. The Eucharist, in particular, speaks to people in countless different ways about a variety of ideas and themes central to their faith and their lives. Because it is primarily a congregational sacrament, it often conveys the idea of membership, incorporation in a community, which may be powerfully felt by persons temporarily isolated by illness or other circumstances. Because its symbols are common food and drink, it usually conveys the idea of sustenance. Because, unlike baptism, it is repeatable, it is available to believers at a wide variety of times in life. To administer the Eucharist is thus often a powerful act of pastoral care (even though, it is many other things, as well). A consideration of the pastoral care aspects of the sacraments includes the recognition that their use is not without risk. The use of the Eucharist with the sick must be very carefully planned and needs prior interpretation. Every hospital chaplain has seen hospitalized believers terrified at the appearance of a minister with the elements of communion—it has felt to them like an omen of impending death. An almost converse risk is that ritual may be interpreted by more naive congregants as an act of magic, with automatic saving power, as if God could be manipulated by it. Such an interpretation gravely undercuts its value as an aspect of pastoral care. The Use of Ritual in Pastoral Care and Counseling Pastoral counselors and counseling agencies surround their clients with rituals. The routines of the office, the waiting room setting, the patterned way of beginning an hour, and other such regularities all form rituals, in which client and counselor alike participate. To be sure, such rituals are of a slightly different sort than those we have been discussing, but they convey similar meanings. In particular, the rituals used in a counseling office provide a sense of identity and regularity, which may be reassuring or annoying to the client. (More often it is reassuring.) When we approach the use of ritual in pastoral care and counseling, we are treading on more difficult ground. It may be useful to cite two concrete incidents, one in the context of pastoral counseling, the other of pastoral care. The first took place in the context of a pastoral counseling center, where a counselor was working with a middle-aged client, whom we shall call Eloise. In one session, the hour was almost over. Eloise, frightened about her immediate future, was talking about her fears. Part of the fear came from her own past and her unusual childhood; part of it came from real dangers she was facing. She got up to leave, reached the door, and turned to stare at the pastoral counselor with a particularly intense look. The counselor remembered how often Eloise had spoken of her attachment to Zenna Henderson's "?people?" stories. The client, whose relationship with her own congregation was conflictual, would have rejected a "?church?" ritual, although she was a woman of faith. The counselor touched her forehead, and quoting a line of blessing from a Zenna Henderson story very familiar to Eloise, said, "?Go under the Protection.?" Months later, as the work was terminating, the client asked the counselor if she remembered the moment, and the counselor said, "?Yes.?" "?That,?" said the client, "?was what turned everything around. I knew then that I could make it.?" The other story comes from a theological seminary, where a professor of New Testament took a strong pastoral interest in his students. Birgit, a student in her mid-thirties, realized with dismay that her marriage was irretrievably lost. She secured a divorce, but for more than a year afterward went about her work in the classroom crippled by guilt. She undertook a summer quarter of clinical pastoral education, but her supervisor reported similar "?crippling?" in that setting. When she returned to school, the professor provided pastoral care for her in several conversations. One day, after a conversation with his colleague in the Pastoral Care Department, the professor decided to offer a ritualized form of care to Birgit. Student and instructor planned the brief ritual together, but the professor told her that he wanted to be free to handle some aspects of the event in his own way. The professor, in alb and purple stole, stood with Birgit and a dozen of her friends in the seminary chapel. The group read a prayer of confession in unison, and the professor read an assurance of pardon. Then he handed her a canvas book bag, which she held open. Into the bag, the professor and the friends dumped pictures, books, and other items connected with her marriage. Then they stood silently for a few moments as Birgit held the now very heavy bag. Then one of Birgit's friends took one handle of the bag and shared the weight. Again they stood that position for a few moments, and then the professor reached over and drew Birgit's wedding ring (which she had put on for the ritual) from her finger, and dropped it in the bag. Again, in silence, they held their positions. Finally, in what to Birgit was a surprise, the professor brought out a large pair of garden shears and severed the handles of the bag. It dropped to the stone floor with a thud. Birgit knelt, and the group gathered around in silence, laying their hands on her head. After silence, the professor said, "?Go in peace,?" and the group quietly left the chapel. The difficulties did not disappear overnight, but Birgit later said that this ceremony had marked the beginning of her healing. Several issues connected with the use of ritual in pastoral care and counseling are visible in these two stories. Whether what was done in either case was wise or valid will of course depend upon the point of view from which one starts. For example, a pastoral counselor working from a psychodynamic perspective will probably find the blessing given to Eloise a problem. What was the meaning of the client's intense stare? Is it not probable that her look was an expression of transference, that she wanted her counselor-mother to save her from her anxiety? That, of course, is quite possible. The counselor saw it differently. Though not unaware of transference issues, she knew that Eloise saw her and knew her as a clergywoman of Eloise's own denomination. She had already preached and baptized a baby in a worship service, where Eloise was in attendance. More than anything else, she saw her primary identity as that of pastor and chose to function with the ascribed power of the pastoral role. A far more urgent question in the counselor's mind was whether Eloise could accept and integrate any blessing. In retrospect, it seemed clear that the blessing and the "?protection?" were used by the client to provide a firm "?working place?" from which to wrestle with a number of anxiety-provoking issues. It is interesting to contrast the scene in the counselor's office with the one in the seminary chapel. The post-divorce ritual was an instance of pastoral care in ritualized form, extended in a group setting (involving the recipient's relevant community of faith), while the "?Henderson blessing?" took place in a pastoral counseling context and involved only counselor and client. Those are significant differences. Transference, though present in the teacher-student relationship, was not an issue or a problem in the ritual; and the professor's standing as a representative figure in a faith community was made even clearer by the invitation to other members of the faith community to be present. A useful principle can be surmised from this discussion. In a pastoral care context, the minister is functioning as a figure representing a faith community, and members of the community may even be present. In a pastoral counseling context, the relationship is more personalized and almost never are representatives from the community present. This does not necessarily mean that a pastoral counselor should never use a ritual of some sort; but it is a caution against careless use that can easily be misinterpreted. Prayer The single most frequent question raised about ritual in pastoral care and counseling has to do with prayer. Typical is the instance of the client in a church-sponsored counseling center. She was a moderately active member of a congregation that called itself evangelical; the counselor was a minister in the same denomination, but not connected with her particular congregation. After several months of satisfying work, she suddenly reported to the counselor that some of her friends were advising her to terminate work with him because he was not praying with her at every counseling session. Typical, too, is this story of the recently ordained minister, who regularly prayed with everyone he visited in homes and hospitals. He was astounded when one of the elderly women he called on asked him not to pray with her. He was inclined to attribute the request to a supposed lack of religious conviction on her part, until she pointed out that the things he prayed about were seldom her real concerns. These two true stories serve as a caution that always and never are dangerous words to use in any instance of pastoral care. Those who always pray or who never pray (aloud) run the risk that we always run when we substitute routines for thinking. Prayer in pastoral care situations need to be based on the attitudes and needs of the parishioner. That caution extends to the way in which prayer is offered. Nico ter Linden tells the story of an uneducated, deeply religious Catholic, who on his death bed pleaded with his priest, "?Cain't ya please stop prayin?' out of book??" (In the Lord's Boarding House [Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1985]). But he also tells of one of his own Dutch Reformed parishioners, who insisted that the Christmas Eve service was not complete unless the minister used the ancient Latin formula, Puer nobis natus est. Ministry to particular individuals depends on the pastor's knowledge of those individuals' particularities. In pastoral counseling, there are likely to be fewer situations, in which prayer will seem appropriate, primarily because people struggling with difficult issues often have a tendency toward the use of prayer, either as a defense or as magic to avoid facing difficult problems or to alter situations magically. The underlying principles are the same, however. Always praying or never praying are both loaded with dangers. There is no substitute for being aware of, and thinking carefully about, the particularities of the individual one is working with. We often long for rules, which will tell us specifically, definitively, what we should and should not do. That longing is built, by the way, on the same dynamic foundations as the neurotic use of rituals of which psychoanalysts are so suspicious. No absolute rules can be offered. But we are in a position to set down some general principles which can guide counselors and caregivers. Any given ritual may have a meaning for the person who decides to use it different from meanings held by other participants. Thus it is important that the participants make sure that their use of the ritual has a similar meaning to all involved. Rituals which involve only two people are likely to carry with them more dangers, than those which involve other representatives of a community. Whenever a community puts in the hands of some representative person the authority to conduct particular rituals, that person will be seen as having some kind of power. Psychologically, this process is akin to the transference; sociologically, it involves what is called ascribed power. Situations involving transference or ascribed power always carry the possibility of misuses, a pos-sibility which is decreased when more than two people are involved. This is particularly true of rituals involving body movement and/or touch. Nevertheless, the value of touch is very great, particularly in situations involving anything approximating a blessing. Praying with sick or grieving folk and offering them a blessing or a benediction ought whenever possible to involve touch. Pruyser writes, "?most pastors … do [this] almost instinctively, because they know '?in their bones?' that tragic situations always call for some kind of touch, some kind of effortless self-giving, some direct, primitive, unreflected, spontaneous spilling over of affect into the motor system?" (Willaim B. Oglesby, ed., The New Shape of Pastoral Theology [Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1969], 362). Although rituals may be constructed for a specific situation, it is valuable to make use of already existing rituals whenever possible. Sometimes it isn't possible. No ritual exists for a given situation; or the ones that do are inadequate. But in general something that is done once to meet a specific need (a) is not a ritual in the first place, and (b) will probably be constructed with too little regard for principles underlying good use of words or of movement. Pastoral care is deeply and powerfully associated with ritual, a fact that we are only recently beginning to recover. There exists—there has always existed—danger that rituals will be misused, but principles do exist for the guidance of pastors and counselors. Meanwhile, there are dangers ever deeper in avoiding and neglecting this fundamental pastoral resource.
Discuss This Topic with AI Worship CoachBrowse Structured Courses