downloadTheology & History
The Postcatechumenate
Following baptism at Easter Vigil, the RCIA concludes with a period of reflection on the purpose and significance of Christian baptism. Following the practice of the early church, this is known as a period of mystagogy, a time of instruction into the meaning of what is now part of lived experience.
In the published editions of the Rite of Christian Initiation of Adults, the section dealing with the period of postbaptismal catechesis or mystagogy occupies a scant two pages. The terse prose of the ritual book is striking. The text gives only the briefest glimpse at how this fourth major period of formation in the Christian way is to be carried out. In the early days of the implementation of the RCIA, little attention was given to this period. Most parish RCIA teams arrived at Easter Sunday morning so exhausted that little energy was left for the "?how?" and "?what?" of mystagogy. Eventually, a popular wisdom emerged that claimed this was the time to teach about sacraments and to introduce neophytes to various parish organizations and ministries. The RCIA folks would maintain a regular weekly schedule of meetings, but now the focus would be on presentations of sacramental theology and visits by parish leaders, who saw the occasion as an ideal opportunity to recruit new workers for their particular area of concern. Today there seems to be a new maturity developing regarding mystagogy. Many are realizing that those attempts were well-meaning but misplaced. RCIA teams are returning to the ritual book to read again numbers 244–251; and more careful reflection is being given to just what this period of formation is supposed to be about. A better understanding of initiation has helped us see the period of the catechumenate—not the period of mystagogy—as the proper time to "?introduce?" candidates and catechumens to the understanding of sacrament and to the ministerial life of the community. If a community has waited until mystagogy to present the notions of sacrament, mission, and ministry, then formation of the catechumen has been incomplete. We no longer live in the fifth century, when mystagogy is the time we tell new members the "?secrets?" of our faith, either about sacraments or the Christian mission. However, mystagogy in our day still needs to be very much a time of learning about sacrament and mission in new ways. The challenge faced by RCIA teams, then, is how best to accomplish the mystagogical task, i.e., how best to do postbaptismal catechesis in a way that will help neophytes to appreciate in new and vital ways the meaning of belonging to a sacramental community, whose focus is the Christian mission. It is interesting how easily we can overlook things that are obvious. Many who are returning to the rite for direction with the period of mystagogy are struck by how clearly it says that the primary focus of our pastoral energies during this period should be what happens in the Sunday assembly, not on gatherings during the week or on efforts to "?connect?" neophytes to parish organizations. For those who must make the practical decisions regarding "?how to do it?" during mystagogy, it is obvious that their attention needs to be, first and foremost, on what happens in the Sunday assembly. Reflection on the historical roots of mystagogical catechesis confirms that this insight is on target. The classic examples of mystagogy bequeathed to us by the ancient church can all be found in the midst of the liturgical gathering. Mystagogy was what the bishop-homilist did, in the presence of the neophytes and the rest of the community, as they gathered to celebrate the new life that had been poured out during the night of the Great Vigil. The homilies were recognized as important statement for the entire community; they were recorded and circulated widely from the very beginning. Their aim was not just to comment on the immediate experience of those gathered. Rather, the bishop's mystagogical homilies were major statements, which attempted to articulate the foundational meanings of Christian belonging in a way that would shape and direct the community's life all year long. RCIA strategists on the eve of the twenty-first century need to develop ways to recapture something of that significance for their own local communities. In this regard, the intuitions of our early efforts to implement RCIA were correct: understanding sacrament, and mission are crucial to the success of the mystagogical task. Or, to express it more accurately, a proper understanding of the linkage between sacrament and mission is the key to the success of the period of mystagogy. The rite gives several cues that signal the importance of the Sunday gathering. It suggests that the neophytes sit together as a group, preferably with godparents and sponsors, and that general intercessions and homily be keyed to their presence. The involvement of the entire community is called for, and cycle A readings of the lectionary are recommended for use. In fact, a careful reading of those texts seems foundational to any elaboration of the meaning of mystagogy. In those readings, the themes of new life, belonging to community, sacramental participation, and Christian mission are intimately intertwined. Those responsible for the period of mystagogy will want to call for careful reflection on those texts by all who are involved in setting the direction of parish life. Practically speaking, that means an invitation to the homilists to dialogue with selected parish leadership (or RCIA catechists or others) regarding the vision of Christian life offered to the neophytes in those texts. Long before the immediate task of homily preparation, the homilist needs to be involved reflecting on these texts as foundational for the life of the parish community. In particular, those who are part of this reflection must wrestle with the connection between sacramental participation and commitment to the Christian mission. What better time in a parish's life to reexamine policies regarding sacramental preparation and the call to conversion that must be clearly part of a parish's way of celebrating the sacrament? What better context in which to discuss stewardship in a parish? The readings will see to it that the focus is not just on money gathering. Instead, they make it clear that we are all gifted by the Spirit for the upbuilding of the community and the spread of the gospel. Christian mission, in the vision of these readings, is set in its proper context as a consequence of a community's encounter with the risen one in sacramental celebration. In this sacramental encounter, we are gifted in an incredibly rich fashion as the Spirit is poured forth upon us and we are nourished at the Lord's Table. If the RCIA team is able to convoke gatherings to reflect on the meaning of the mystagogical texts for the life of the parish community, then it will be a logical next step to use the homily time to expand the dialogue to the wider community. Some homilists may be willing to engage in actual dialogue with the assembly regarding the foundational meanings that have been identified in the earlier reflections. Imagine asking long-time parishioners to stand up and tell neophytes what it is that is expected of them by way of Christian mission, now that they have "?completed?" their initiation! Or, imagine inviting the neophytes to give witness to how they hear the Scripture readings calling them to Christian mission! However it is accomplished, what seems essential in order for authentic mystagogical catechesis to occur, is that the neophytes and the community together engage in serious reflection on how our encounter with the risen Lord in the sacraments calls us to Christian mission in the world. The bulk of our remarks have been devoted to how the RCIA team should focus its energies on the Sunday celebration during the time of mystagogy. This has been a deliberate choice, and one which in many communities will require a significant rethinking of "?job descriptions?" and priorities. It may even be distressing to those whose practical bent wants only a list of how-to's. The decision to focus on the Sunday gathering—and especially preparation for the proclamation of a mystagogical homily—is, however, an eminently "?practical?" choice. Yet, we do not wish to suggest that our efforts at mystagogy stop with the Sunday gathering. In fact, other efforts do need to be put forth that will help neophytes assimilate and integrate their new experiences. This means that there will have to be gatherings outside of the Sunday assembly, when leaders will help them unpack the meanings implicit in the powerful rituals which they have experienced at the Vigil. They need also to be helped to articulate how their new experience of eucharistic participation and their new sense of belonging to the community will shape and define their Christian faith in the future. Certainly, there will to some extent be a place for helping them sort out new ministerial involvements and new ways of living Christian mission. But that should come as a consequence of the meanings which are unfolded, rather than being presented as a recruitment event to fill out committee membership rolls. In planning for the period of mystagogy, emphasis must always be on sharing the meaning of our being in Christ, not just on our doing.