Back to Media & Articles Library
downloadTheology & History

The Relationship Between Private And Public Worship

ByWendy J. Miller

Genuine worship and prayer is extremely difficult in the hurried pace of everyday life. Stress and busyness reduce not only the time we spend in prayer and worship but also the attention and energy we bring to it. This article reflects on the importance of opening ourselves to the awareness of God's presence in both private and public worship.

Most of us in the Protestant tradition have learned that worship and prayer mean addressing God. Whether saying prayers or singing hymns of adoration, confession, or supplication, we tend to think of prayer and worship as isolated actions. This understanding grows out of our experience within our faith tradition and our culture, and informs how we view both communal and private worship. Rather than being the initiators and sole doers of prayer and worship, the Scriptures and our experience inform us that God is the great initiator. God created us, began the relationship; and throughout the Scriptures we discover God continuing to be the initiator. Our worship and our praying, then, are responses to the God who has already invited us, drawn us, spoken to us, and desires to be in relationship with us (Matt. 1:23; John 14:23; Rom. 8:14–16; Rev. 3:20). This brief discussion of congregational and private worship grows out of this assumption: that God, the great Creator, Lover, Redeemer, Healer, invites us home to himself. Worship and prayer arise from within our deepest hope and longings that we have a place to be at home (Luke 13). This same Lord God shows up among us in Jesus Christ (John 14:8–9). Since Pentecost, God is the self-giving participant, coming through the mysterious but concrete presence of the Holy Spirit, joining to our spirit and assisting us in our presence before God as we pray and worship (John 4:23–24; Rom. 8:15–16, 26). Sabbath Rest While I am not advocating any legalistic observation of the Sabbath, the Scriptures do carry God's repeated invitations to rest from work. God is not against work. God is the Creator and giver of fruitful labor (Gen. 1:28; 2:15), but God also invites us to cease the productive mastery that work involves in order that we may relocate ourselves and be reminded of who we are: children of the loving Creator-Redeemer God. Our work moves us by necessity into various roles: pastor, professor, baker, bricklayer, mother, father, doctor, and so on. So also the various roles we embrace designate what tasks and responsibilities are ours to fulfill. God's invitation to Sabbath rest is to cease from defining ourselves in terms of roles and what we do, and to simply be. In the presence of God, we are all children of God, children who are dependent on God as Creator and Sustainer. This willingness to cease from our roles and our work and all the significance and self-importance we attach to them is what Jesus talks to his disciples about: "?Truly I tell you, unless you change and become like children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven?" (Matt. 18:3). During prayer and worship, we experience this profound shift, a coming home to who we truly are in the image and in the presence of God through the saving work of our Lord Jesus Christ. Being Attentive to the Presence of God in the Gathered Community This presence to ourselves or to God is not encouraged or assisted by the world's compulsive pace, which drives and controls that addictive part of ourselves—our old nature. The desire of God is to indwell the people of God through the Spirit of Christ (John 14:16–17); God is present, but often we are not at home. We are absent from ourselves. The pace of our culture, and often of our church life and of what we call ministry, blurs our senses and dulls our awareness as we spiral downward into anesthetized exhaustion. Once there, we seek to numb the pain and stress loaded upon us through such compulsive living by escaping into television, video games, eating, and so on. In that state of mind, we view vacations as a further chance to escape and may tend to think of "?doing devotions?" as intrusive or tainted with religious effort and drudgery. We would do well to remember that as we and others join the gathered community to worship, we often become jostled, overstimulated, overworked, and overinformed by that constant stream of sound bites that speed endlessly forth from modern technology's addiction for information. To assist our awareness of the presence for God and our sense of being part of the gathered body, we need a gentle invitation to be present to ourselves, to come home to ourselves. The move may be consciously or unconsciously painful, for most of us do suffer some kind of pain from the feverish life we live. This life is destructive to that deep and genuine bonding in the Spirit of Christ. Silence, quiet music, hymns, and acts of coming or gathering are those forms of communal spiritual disciplines that can assist us in this journey from absence to presence. The Psalms, or some modern version of the psalmist's experience, can be a guide. Over half of the Psalter is some form of lament or complaint, words given to clothe our pain and stress so that in its naming and owning we are guided into the gracious, listening presence of God. The invitation in all the movements of worship is to open ourselves to the God who is present: "?For where two or three are gathered in my name, I am there among them?" (Matt. 18:20). Attention needs to be paid during the leading of worship to those words or acts that assist the presence of God and to that which kidnaps a person out of that presence. Worship leaders who are mindful of their own sense of God's presence will be better able to assist the gathered community in developing the same sense. When we are involved with God at the deepest level of our being, then casual or rote ritual is impossible, whether our ritual is formal liturgy or the spontaneous prayers of the free-church tradition. Such attention for God requires time and space. It cannot be rushed or coerced. However, it can be encouraged and assisted. We are often timid, like deer stepping gingerly into a clearing, always alert for danger. Meeting God in the open space of worship can be marked by fear, especially if the authority figures in our life have been demanding, legalistic, or abusive. Even the disciples needed time and special help in understanding what God is really like. "?'?Lord, show us the Father, and we will be satisfied.?' Jesus said to them, '?Whoever has seen me has seen the Father?'?" (John 14:8–9). We may know this in our head, but in our actual experience we may be reluctant to open ourselves to God. The continual retelling of the Good News, the story of our salvation by grace through faith in the Lord Jesus, gradually stills our fears. We enter bit by bit into the Sabbath grace and the rest of worship (Matt. 11:28–30; Heb. 4:14–16). We come home. What assists one in his or her awareness of God's presence may not assist another. Jesus stands among us, knocking at the door of our awareness (Rev. 3:20). For one, the door may be music; for another, the Scripture reading; and for another, prayer or silence. We can be expectant for God comes to us through all the doors and paths of the soul. As we gather in this awareness, we can be more patient and compassionate toward those who do not seem to enjoy or embrace those forms of worship that seem so vital to us. We may also seek to open ourselves more fully to all parts of the worship experience, even those parts that seem to bore us. Sometimes boredom is a device of our dysfunctional and old nature that helps it to avoid being present to God, to ourselves, or to others. Allowing nonhurried space and silence for meditative attentiveness and presence can be gradually introduced into our gathered life. Some guidance can be helpful, rather than leaving persons to wander around in their thoughts in an empty silence. This can become a problem in an age where silence is viewed as a waste of time or as an empty space that needs to be instantly filled with something—preferably sound. Presence for God is not always accompanied by rich or marked experience. Such experiences do happen. Peter, James, and John were overwhelmed by their experience as God addressed them: "?This is my Son, the Beloved; with him I am well pleased; listen to him!?" (Matt. 17:5). Peter wanted to stay with that experience on the mountain. Although the experience was rich, powerful, and full of wonder, God directed the focus of the disciples through that experience to Jesus: "?Listen to him!?" In the same way, Jesus redirected the focus of the seventy after they reported on the way they had experienced God's power in casting out demons: "?Do not rejoice at this, that the spirits submit to you, but rejoice that your names are written in heaven?" (Luke 10:20). Again, he points to God's realm and the work of salvation he is accomplishing for them. Just so, as we worship, the experience we receive of God is a wonder and a consolation. But the experience is part of our ongoing transformation into the image of Christ and an invitation to gaze upon our Lord Jesus, to have our focus redirected so that God fills our horizon. Then worship arises within us, and we adore in spirit and in truth. Being Attentive to Presence in Solitude While the retelling of the acts of God through Scripture, liturgy, drama, sacrament, or the spoken Word holds a central place in the worship of the gathered community, those retellings can deteriorate into dry ritual and form unless the individual members of the community are open and attentive to God's presence within them and among them. This attentiveness on the part of each individual is a vital link between congregational and private worship. The gathered community encourages each individual to remain faithful to God in the solitude of their lives and vocation in the world. And the day-by-day presence for God on the part of the individual breathes an open space into the heart, where worship with the gathered community resounds and echoes with God's lively presence. Jesus modeled a pattern for his followers, a rhythm of private prayer and worship that flowed into fruitful activity among people. This pattern weaves its way throughout his life and finally the lives of his disciples. In Mark 3:13–15, Jesus trekked up the mountain to a place apart and then called to him "?those whom he wanted, and they came to him … to be with him, and to be sent out to proclaim the message, and to have authority to cast out demons.?" We have paid much attention in the church to being sent out and to proclaiming the message but very little attention to leaving our daily activity and turning aside to simply be with Jesus. Private worship is this simple but profound act of being with. Jesus offered a simple pathway to solitude: "?Whenever you pray, go into your room and shut the door and pray to your Father who is in secret; and your Father who sees in secret will reward you?" (Matt. 6:6). This turning aside from the daily activity, coming into that chosen place, and shutting the door to all the other voices and influences that seek to mold and mark our life is part of the rhythm. Again, we cease the labor of our various roles and rediscover our identity as children in the gracious, listening presence of the God who sees. Jesus delighted in explaining what God is like to the persons who gathered around him from abusive, dysfunctional familial, national, and religious systems. In this Matthew passage is an echo of Hagar's experience of God in Genesis 16. The Egyptian slave girl was caught up in the struggle of Abram and Sarai, who decided to start doing God's work for God rather than waiting on God to act. However, Sarai found herself hostile and anger towards Hagar, especially when the slave girl became pregnant with Abram's child, something Sarai had been unable to do. Sarai dealt harshly with Hagar, and the slave woman finally ran away. Pregnant, rejected, alone, she wanders in the wilderness. But God sees her and helps this woman, who had been used and abused, to find her way back home. Out of this experience, Hagar knows who God is for her: El-roi, God who sees. We may not always come into the room in our house feeling like a child who is welcomed and embraced by a loving God who sees us in secret. We may feel more like Hagar, an alien and a wanderer, discounted and at risk. But the God who sees is present. As we come into the place, we are desiring to be found. No private prayer or act of worship is truly disconnected from the larger praying community. As each of us grow in our faithful response to God, so the gathered community is gradually transformed in its faithfulness to God and God's purposes. This transformation is assisted as we can give ourselves to the practice of spiritual disciplines, both corporate and private. Spiritual disciplines also assist us in our presence for God, both in the place of solitude and as we act in our vocation in the world. Today a growing number of books are available to help us rediscover what the early Christians knew and practiced in their lives of worship and discipleship. Each spiritual discipline is simply a pathway into the presence of God and can be evaluated in that light. Does this prayer form assist me in my presence for God or block my spiritual attentiveness? Different disciplines suit different persons because of personality type, of religious background and experience, and of where a person is in their journey of discipleship and friendship with Christ. There is a growing awareness of the need for spiritual friends or directors who are gifted and trained in assisting that necessary discernment between the movement of God's Spirit in a person's life and the response of that person to God's presence and work, within oneself and in relationship with others. Sometimes in the solitary space, alone in God's presence, the prophetic voice emerges. The faithful worshiper is given discernment and wisdom for the guidance of the gathered community. Also, in the presence of God, we become aware of our true humanity and our humility, and can speak wisdom with grace, meekness, and poise rather than with force, arrogance, and defensiveness. Congruence between Personal and Corporate Worship I have begun to wonder how much congruence exists between how persons experience worship in private and how they are assisted in worship as they gather in a community. I also wonder if the congregation and the persons responsible for planning worship stop to question how they are assisting others in their awareness of God's presence as they plan the sequence and content of the worship service. While we cannot program God's revelation of himself to us, we are invited by God to be attentive and present to God. Those of us who are helping to plan and lead the various elements of worship could begin by paying quiet attention to our own experience of God. What assists us to be present and attentive to God? And what prevents us? A worship-planning committee that spends a prayerful hour or two reflecting on these questions can be more attuned to where we as a congregation are. They can be more attuned to those elements that help us as we gather in community to be aware of the presence of the living and loving Christ within and among
Discuss This Topic with AI Worship CoachBrowse Structured Courses