downloadTheology & History
The Wesleyan Church
Wesleyans have in the past typically emphasized the pulpit over the sacraments. Although Wesleyan theology identifies these sacraments as a means of grace and accept many different forms or modes of these sacraments as legitimate, many members have tended to view them more as an opportunity for personal testimony. However, recent worship renewal has drawn the church to more of a balance between the preaching of the Word and the administering of the sacraments.
At their ordination, ministers in the Wesleyan Church are charged to preach the Word and administer the sacraments. In the life of the church, though, preaching is obviously the dominant assignment. Like other churches in the Holiness movement, the Wesleyan Church is a non-sacramental denomination. The pulpit, not the Table, has always been central in the service, and priority is given to the sacred Word, rather than to sacred actions. Still, the sacraments are not neglected or ignored. In Wesleyan congregations, the two historic Protestant sacraments are celebrated—baptism and the Lord's Supper. According to the Wesleyan Discipline, each is considered a means of grace, but the popular perception of the sacraments seems slanted more toward the understanding of it as personal testimony. God's presence is seldom associated with the sacraments, being acknowledged instead in the promise of his presence in corporate worship (Matthew 18:20) and in the moving of his Spirit in the services. (Not surprisingly, Wesleyans often sense that divine movement during the sacraments. Perhaps it is at this point that theology meets praxis!) Baptism may be "?the water that divides?" for some, (the title of a study by Donald Bridge and David Phypers, The Water That Divides [Downers Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press, 1977]), but not for Wesleyans. On the sacramental shoals of who and how, Wesleyans steer a course which is intentionally inclusive. Baptism, with all its attendant controversies, is no potential barrier to fellowship in the church. Both infant and believer's baptism are provided for in the Wesleyan Discipline, and both are consistent with the Wesleyan spirit. Infant baptism has always been affirmed in the Methodist family of churches; in the Twenty-Five Articles of Methodism, John Wesley specifically instructed that it was to be retained. Holiness churches in the Methodist tradition have continued that practice. Believer's baptism, on the other hand, is appropriate to the evangelistic impulse of the Wesleyan movement, particularly as the gospel is offered to those for whom infant baptism was not available in their own traditions. In practice, however, believer's baptism is much more common in the Wesleyan Church, and paedobaptism is viewed with reservation. In fact, those previously baptized as infants are often rebaptized in the church, despite the decidedly un-Wesleyan theology behind such a practice. Even the church Discipline, which offers church members the right to have their infants baptized, describes baptism in its Articles of Religion as a sacrament "?administered to believers?" by which "?believers declare their faith in Jesus Christ as Savior?" (The Discipline of the Wesleyan Church [Indianapolis: Wesley Press, 1988], 27). It follows then, that far more children are dedicated than are baptized in Wesleyan circles. (The preface to the ritual of "?The Dedication and Baptism of Infants?" is very Zwinglian, speaking of "?dedicat(ing a child) through the sacrament of baptism.?" For many of these observations on the Wesleyan position on infant baptism, I am indebted to Rob L. Staples, Outward Sign and Inward Grace: The Place of Sacraments in Wesleyan Spirituality [Kansas City: Beacon Hill Press, 1991]). As for how, baptism is available in all three modes—immersion, sprinkling, and pouring. Immersion is the most frequently practiced; pouring is by far the least. Whatever the mode, Christian baptism is a requirement for church membership, although in many congregations a new convert may actually be received into membership in anticipation of future baptism. The Lord's Table is always open in the Wesleyan Church, and that phrase involves more than a universal invitation to all Christians, regardless of denominational affiliation. It also means that Wesleyans see Communion (to use its more common designation in the church) as an opportunity for evangelism, and thus the sacrament is open to repentant sinners. The invitation in the ritual is not only to "?you who are walking in fellowship with God,?" but also to "?you who do truly and earnestly repent of your sin and intend to lead a new life?"(Discipline 404). Communion is offered "?at least once each three months?" (Discipline 34), a schedule which ironically is indebted to Zwingli and not Wesley, who was a very frequent communicant. In keeping with the church's stand on abstinence from alcohol, grape juice is used in place of wine. Usually, the sacrament is received kneeling at the Communion rail. Other sacred actions beyond the two sacraments find occasional usage in Wesleyan congregations. Anointing the sick is generally done on request, although at least one sizable church in the denomination schedules services for that purpose quarterly. (Medical and professional care are always seen as appropriate extensions of prayers for divine healing, if necessary.) Footwashing is not a Wesleyan tradition, but it has been employed in special contexts. Congregations which prepare their children for membership may use their reception ritual much like confirmation. Another sacred action familiar to the entire church is ordination. The decision to ordain is made by a district conference of ministers and laity, not by a local church, and typically the ordination occurs at that same conference. (Ordained ministers were called elders until the terminology was changed at the 1992 General Conference.) Lay ministers may be commissioned to a variety of assignments in the church, with prescribed courses of study and rituals tailored to their callings. Worship renewal is not widespread in the Wesleyan Church, but it is beginning to have a noticeable impact. Some congregations have increased the frequency of the Lord's Supper (usually to a monthly schedule). Expanded observance of the Christian year in the church is accompanied by increased opportunities for the sacrament. Variation on the customary wafer and individual cup at the Communion rail is no longer news in the pews. Wesleyans are becoming comfortable with alternative approaches, particularly intinction (dipping the bread into a common cup). Without retreating from its historic emphasis on the Word read and preached, the Wesleyan Church's growing appreciation for sacred actions is a step toward a better worship balance.